Term Paper on "Freedom of Speech Morse v. Frederick"
Term Paper 4 pages (1461 words) Sources: 5 Style: MLA
[EXCERPT] . . . .
Freedom of SpeechMorse v. Frederick - Freedom of Speech
The issue of freedom of speech has very often been misunderstood and misinterpreted by American citizens who believe they can say anything they want or print anything they want in any contest. But as the case of Morse v. Frederick points out, there are limits to what can be stated, where, and when something could be considered to be out of bounds as far as the Constitution is concerned.
On the surface, the ruling by the Supreme Court in Morse v. Frederick simply defines and tightens the legal interpretation of the Free Speech Clause of the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, and finds that school-age kids can't display signs (even if in jest, or through parody) that appear to advocate the use of illegal drugs. On a broader level, a political level, the decision shows those members of the public who are paying attention to what happens in Washington, D.C., that the Bush Administration has delivered to its constituents in its conservative base just what it promised - a far more conservative Court; many observers are wondering - and it is an entirely relevant question to pose - as to how soon (or if) the Bush/Roberts Court will amend or wholly abolish the decision in Roe v. Wade.
Case Brief - Facts of the Case
Morse et al. v. Frederic (Argued March 19, 2007; Decided June 25, 2007)
Facts: A high school student in Alaska unfurled a banner that read "BONG HITS 4 JESUS"; it was a prank during a school recess to observe the passing of the Olympic torch in Alaska.
The student was trying to get on TV; the princ
download full paper ⤓
The student (Frederick) claimed (and the 9th Circuit Court agreed) that he was punished unjustly because the school had not demonstrated that his "speech" "threatened substantial disruption" (Bench Opinion, Supreme Court).
Statute at issue: Free Speech Clause of the First Amendment
Legal question for Court: Did Frederick have a First Amendment right to "wield his banner" - no matter that it appeared to advocate a controversial issue?
The outcome: the Court ruled against Frederick, on a 5-4 decision.
Majority ruling written by Justice Roberts: The Court agreed with high school principal
Morse, that first, the banner appeared to be pro-drug, and hence in violation of school policy (Roberts cited Guiles v. Marineau in which a middle school student was suspended for wearing a t-shirt with pro-drug and anti-Bush messages); and second, that schools may take steps "to safeguard those entrusted to their care from speech that can reasonably be regarded as encouraging illegal drug use" (Roberts, 2007, No. 06-278).
Legal doctrine: this is a significant case because school districts in the future will assume that they can take action against certain questionable student activities - during which students may claim "free speech" - based on this interpretation of the Constitution by the Court. Roberts alluded to Hazelwood School Dist. V. Kuhlmeier in contending that rights of students "must be 'applied in light of the special characteristics of the school environment" (Roberts, 2007).
Other opinions: Justice Souter asked, "What would be disorderly" about unfurling a banner with a silly statement on it? "I don't see what [the banner] disrupts, unless disruption simply means any statement of disagreement with a position officially adopted by the school" (the Rutherford Institute, 2007). Justice Ginsburg: If the sign had said "BONG STINKS for JESUS" and the school principal had the identical reaction, "...that this was demeaning to the Olympics and it was unruly conduct," would that act then be "...a protected right under Tinker because the message was not promoting drugs?"
Key Decisions in this area
This case is based on the Civil Liberties of citizens as spelled out in the First Amendment of the Constitution - the Free Speech Clause.
On page 475 of Epstein & Walker's text, the authors point out that Americans regard the Bill of Rights as "an enumeration of our most cherished freedoms," and that includes the "right to speak freely..." But what exactly does the Constitution mean by "speak freely"? That is ultimately the job of the Supreme Court. 1) Tinker v. Des Moines School Dist (1969) (393 U.S. 503) was a case in which students protesting U.S. involvement in the Vietnam war came… READ MORE
Quoted Instructions for "Freedom of Speech Morse v. Frederick" Assignment:
“This essay must be an exploratory essay.
Part 1: state initial ideas about the issue based on personal experience and readings recently encountered/ researched.
Part 2: exploring the sources => what are the values expressed in the writing? How are the reasons supported? What would happen if the *****'s ideas were put into place? How does the ***** take into account opposing viewpoints?
Part 3: The conclusion => discuss the results of the exploration whatever they were. This section is about where you stand now, but need not to be final or conclusive. *****
How to Reference "Freedom of Speech Morse v. Frederick" Term Paper in a Bibliography
“Freedom of Speech Morse v. Frederick.” A1-TermPaper.com, 2008, https://www.a1-termpaper.com/topics/essay/freedom-speech-morse/18363. Accessed 5 Oct 2024.
Related Term Papers:
Freedom of Speech Essay
Freedom of Speech
One of the main issues facing every society at large and every representation of society in microcosm -- such as the classroom -- is the balancing of… read more
Essay 3 pages (987 words) Sources: 2 Style: APA Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning
Freedom of Speech There Was Much Debate Essay
Freedom of Speech
There was much debate during the Constitutional Convention about which rights should be given to the new Republic. Many were fearful of "mobocracy" with too many freedoms,… read more
Essay 3 pages (1025 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Journalism / Media / PR / News
Free Speech vs. Discrimination and Harassment Essay
Sexual Harassment and Freedom of Speech
The freedom of speech is considered, by many, to be the most fundamental freedoms. Without free speech it is impossible to… read more
Essay 4 pages (1436 words) Sources: 3 Topic: Communication / Speech
Should Some Kind of Speech Be Censored Essay
Freedom of Speech
When Americans think of what makes their country great, many will bring to mind the various freedoms guaranteed to them in the Bill of Rights. Among the… read more
Essay 5 pages (2004 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Law / Legal / Jurisprudence
Frederick Douglas and Push by Sapphire Essay
Frederick Douglass and Precious Jones are two larger than life figures, who show the world what it takes to become a human being when all the odds are against it.… read more
Essay 4 pages (1403 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning
Sat, Oct 5, 2024
If you don't see the paper you need, we will write it for you!
We can write a new, 100% unique paper!