Thesis on "Troubled Asset Relief Program Tarp Effectiveness"

Thesis 10 pages (3393 words) Sources: 9 Style: APA

[EXCERPT] . . . .

financial crisis and its impacts on the U.S. economy. The TARP program was created to deal with these impacts, and this paper will analyze TARP in terms of its success at addressing the impacts. The program has five main objectives, but can genuinely claim success only in one area thus far. TARP may not end up a failure, but successes are few as of yet.

In the fall of 2008, the financial crisis hit its critical mass. The crisis had been brewing for a couple of years, as the collapse of the housing bubble began to reveal a banking industry that was far too heavily invested in risky mortgages and mortgage-backed securities. First Bear Stearns was acquired to JP Morgan. Then in September two catastrophic banking failures occurred as first Lehman Brothers went under and then the FDIC orchestrated the sale of Washington Mutual to JP Morgan (Dash & Sorkin, 2008). Banks, wary of having too many bad assets on their books, began to constrict credit. Fearful of both the economic impacts of a credit crunch and the panic that would ensue among both the public and investors if more major bank failures occurred, the federal government initiated would be become known as the Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP). This paper will examine TARP and its role in alleviating the financial crisis. Special attention will be paid to the ways in which TARP has achieved its goals and the ways in which it has failed to achieve its goals. TARP was controversial from the outset, with opposition and support coming from both economic conservatives and liberals alike. The outcomes of TARP will also be analyzed in the context of their concerns as well.

The Financial Crisis

It is widely argued, with considerable merit, that the Federal Reserve precipitated the financial crisis in the early part of this decade by holding interest rates at unusually and unsustainable levels. "The Federal Reserve's expansionary monetary policy supplied the means for unsustainable housing prices and unsustainable mortgage financing" (White, 2009). Investors wary of technology stocks were flush with money and seeking a haven. Thus, they turned to real estate. The monetary expansion also left banks with surplus capital to lend. This encouraged them to take on an increasing amount of risk in the form of subprime mortgages. A portion of this risk was then portioned off and sold in the form of allegedly high-grade mortgage-backed securities. When the Fed initiated a rapid increase in rates to slow the monetary expansion in the middle part of the decade, the housing market collapsed. Many of the subprime mortgages were made at low introductory rates, with higher rates improving after a few years. The borrowers were unable to make their new payments at the higher rate, and with housing prices stagnant or worse were also unable to liquidate.

Banks sitting on stockpiles of foreclosures found themselves unable to meet their liabilities or their reserve requirements, and began to restrict their lending as a result. As some banks began to collapse under the weight of their bad assets and others curtailed lending, the economy began to slow and then finally contract.

The problems, therefore, were manifold. The Fed contributed with its monetary expansion. Banks contributed by lowering their lending standards in an attempt to use their excess lending capacity. Consumers contributed by taking on mortgages they could not afford. Investors contributed by adopting a "herd mentality" with respect to the risky bundled securities of subprime mortgages (Tetangco, 2009).

The federal government and the regulators responsible for the banking industry took immediate steps to address the issue. The FDIC began aggressively managing the financial services industry, not just with the takeover of Washington Mutual but eventually with over one hundred other financial institutions as well (Glass, 2009). For its part, the federal government began to take steps to alleviate the distress on the banking industry.

Too Big to Fail

The Bush government, in consultation with a myriad of regulators and the two presidential candidates, acted to draft legislation to protect key financial industry players. The companies were deemed "too big to fail." The phrase, first coined during the Reagan administration -- and applied then to a handful of banks as well -- has been applied by governments multiple times throughout history (Smith & Yandle, 2009). The implication of the phrase is that if the firm that is too big to fail were to fail, that failure would result in considerable economic catastrophe. In the case of major U.S. banks such as Citigroup, AIG and a few other firms during the run of the economic crisis, two factors played into the government's decision to intervene.

The first factor is the interdependency in the financial system. If a major bank were to fail, its creditors would also likely fail. This is especially true during an ongoing financial crisis. The failure of one major firm would precipitate the failure of other firms, who were already in a precarious situation. This would have a spinoff effect, leading to a catastrophic collapse of the economy.

The second factor is the issue of consumer confidence. With housing prices dropping, gas prices high and banks failing, consumer confidence was shattered by the fall of 2008. Any further erosion of confidence, in particular with respect to the soundness of the nation's banking system, would result in a bank run or worse. This would precipitate a financial collapse, with all of the attendant problems.

The case for too big to fail sounds reasonable, but has its critics. Some critics attack the issue on the basis that government should not become involved to such as degree in business. Others take a less fundamental, more pragmatic approach and content that the economy can withstand such failures. Alternatively, it is posited that the banks are encouraged towards risk-taking behavior by the knowledge that they will be bailed out anyway because they are "too big to fail" (Smith & Yandle, 2008).

Smaller banks did not receive the too big to fail designation. The FDIC's role in the banking industry is to monitor the industry and become involved in the liquidation of banks when they become insolvent. Since the onset of the crisis, the FDIC has presided over 100 such liquidations. Aside from the WaMu action, most of the fallen banks have been small and medium sized regional players. The larger banks, however, were deemed too big to fail. Indeed the way in which the takeover of Washington Mutual was orchestrated indicates that the government viewed it as too big to fail as well. Its assets were transferred immediately to JP Morgan, which allowed operations to continue without interruption. The federal government's response to the other banks that were too big to fail was the bailout, which became known as the Troubled Asset Relief Program, or TARP.

Troubled Asset Relief

The troubled assets in question were the bad mortgages and their securitized variants. The securitized versions were marketed as being low risk (often AAA) securities because the risk of default of the mortgages that underlay the securities was believed to have been sufficiently diversified. However, the collapse of the real estate market was nationwide and the emphasis on subprime mortgages was widespread. As a consequence, the securities collapsed. So the troubled assets to be addressed in this bill were both the mortgages and the securities constructed from the mortgages.

TARP's overarching objective was to "improve the strength of financial institutions" (Federal Reserve, 2009), which were precariously weak at the time. This in turn was expected to deliver stability to the economy as a whole and slow the decline in consumer confidence. Essentially, TARP was a desperation move made during desperate times. This point is relevant in particular when evaluating TARP's effectiveness -- it must be weighed against the alternatives posited at the time. The main alternative was to do nothing and let the market forces work the situation out. This is a reasonable expectation if one takes a long-term view of markets and accepts that sometimes the market declines will be steep. This view is, however, not politically expedient, either for an outgoing President keen not to have a recession on his legacy nor an incoming President elected with a mandate to heal the nation's economic situation. The only other viable alternative would have been to do more than what TARP did.

In order to meet this overarching objective, TARP contained a number of key clauses. The first is the purchase of up to $700 billion of the so-called troubled assets from banks. This serves two purposes. The first is that the move clears the assets from the balance sheets of the financial institutions in question. In doing this, the banks are freed up to lend capital. Their capital ratios are stabilized, which allows them to lend again, rather than holding onto their capital. If banks are lending more, then firms are able to acquire capital for projects. In theory, this should first stabilize the economy and then stimulate economic growth… READ MORE

How to Reference "Troubled Asset Relief Program Tarp Effectiveness" Thesis in a Bibliography

Related Thesis Papers:

Tarp and American Auto Companies Thesis

TARP and American Auto Companies

Of the $1.1 trillion in authorized bailout funds for financial firms and banks ($700 billion Troubled Asset Relief Program (TARP) and $400 billion for Fannie… read more

Thesis 8 pages (2747 words) Sources: 6 Style: Turabian Topic: Economics / Finance / Banking

---

Programs for Children in the Foster Care System Research Paper

Programs for Children in the Foster Care System

This paper aims to discuss the United States Foster Care system. It puts light on the trends of entries, exists, adoptions and… read more

Research Paper 12 pages (3771 words) Sources: 12 Topic: Child Development / Youth / Teens

---

Asset and Guest Security O'Dell Gallery Research Paper

ASSET AND GUEST SECURITY O'DELL GALLERY

Security Measures: Protecting Guests and Assets and the O'Dell Art Gallery

Security Measures: Protecting Guests and Assets at the O'Dell Art Gallery

The O'Dell… read more

Research Paper 4 pages (1243 words) Sources: 4 Topic: Business / Corporations / E-commerce

---

Program Evaluation Home and Community-Based Waiver Services Essay

Program Evaluation

Home And Community-Based Waiver Services (HCBS) program is an assistance that allows reimbursement for certain chronically ill, disable and elderly people who are not otherwise covered by the… read more

Essay 25 pages (7215 words) Sources: 7 Topic: Healthcare / Health / Obamacare

---

Program Development Term Paper

Program Development

The program that I am interested in developing is a natural birth information class for patients and nurses at the hospital. The curriculum I will review for this… read more

Term Paper 7 pages (1895 words) Sources: 7 Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>