Essay on "Representing Masculinities in Casino Royale and Fight Club"

Essay 9 pages (3028 words) Sources: 5

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Fight Club and Casino Royale

Representing Masculinity in Fight Club and Casino Royale

If, as R.W. Connell implies, antagonism toward homosexual men may be used to define masculinity, both Chuck Palahniuk's Fight Club and Ian Fleming's Casino Royale exude a kind of machismo that may be categorized as virile. However, the kind of masculinity depicted in Fight Club (both book and film) and in Casino Royale is indicative of a much deeper social trend: the male obsession with gadgets, demeanor, violence, and place. Assuming that masculinity is macho, tough, cool, on-the-edge, and concerned with action, women and cars, both Fight Club and Casino Royale may be viewed as reinforcements of masculinity -- and, conversely, as antagonistic to homosexuality. But while Casino Royale navigates a much more superficial heterosexual fantasy construct, Fight Club deals deftly with the modern male consciousness as it loses all its modern underpinnings. To say that either is an overt commentary on homosexuality may be an overstatement -- but one may suggest without fear that both may be analyzed as representations of heterosexual roles. This paper will analyze the ways in which the definition of homosexuality as the negation of masculinity is both reinforced and challenged in Fight Club and Casino Royale.

Understanding the Masculine Role

Neither work makes any explicit display of antagonism to homosexuality per se, but both do display antagonism to that which is soft according to their own standards of masculinity. The self-admittedly homosexual Palahniuk is also a self-admittedly violent person upon provocation: indeed, the inspiration for Fight Club stemmed from the reactions he received to a black eye he got from a fight in the woods during a camping trip (Fight Club DVD Special Edition 2000). In other words, just because the author is homosexual and the book is preoccupied with unbridled machismo and combat does not necessarily mean the two -- homosexuality and the masculine identity -- are any more than superficially connected. Indeed, Fight Club is a narrative that challenges and reinforces traditional norms simply because it challenges everything in the hero's worldview and ultimately falls back on the traditional values of the Romantic hero. Palahniuk has described himself as neither a nihilist nor a fascist but as a Romantic (Kavadlo 2005:5). The Romantic is typically composed of one part old world and one part new world: at the same time he holds to traditional beliefs -- chivalry, truth, beauty, etc., he also fails to anchor himself in the old world faith -- and sets about attempting to correct the real world with hopelessly idealistic and unrealistic plans.

To this end, Tyler Durden is both savior and bully -- savior because he draws the hero out of the mire of his own lifeless consciousness, and bully because he ultimately fails to allow the hero any real control over his own life. Durden is the epitome of Romantic/Enlightenment doctrine -- but he is not the hero of Fight Club, he is merely the foil. The hero is the nameless narrator, who in the novel is locked away in an asylum at the end and in the film is catapulted to the head of an underground militant group staring into the face of a revolutionary uprising for which he is responsible. David Fincher's film adaptation closes on the image of the world's financial banking institutions collapsing (a prophetic glimpse) and the hero taking Marla's hand in his own, as though they are now responsible for the furtherance of civilization. If consumerism, materialism and corporatism have destroyed the world, erotic love, platonic love, spiritual love, procreation and a good look at real human nature are offered as hopes for the coming future. Fincher's final thrust before the film's credits roll is to splice a clip of an erect penis into the film, as though suggesting that human nature is not for prudes, cannot be suppressed and is not leaving anytime soon: in a word, there is a little Tyler in all of us. If, as Terry Lee comments, "consumer-materialist culture defines masculinity and what men desire," then Fight Club is not about hetero- or homosexuality -- but about "manly efforts to be mature, to be responsible, to be breadwinners in the public sphere, where self-restraint was championed" (Lee 2002:418). Homosexuality may only be read into Fight Club -- just like it can only be read into Casino Royale. Neither work directly addresses the issue of homosexuality. Fight Club does attempt to understand the masculinity of its hero, a lonely man who feels stifled and isolated and wants to reach out to the world. Casino Royale does end with Bond falling in love -- and then losing that love. But Fleming's Bond is as romantic and unreal as Palahniuk's Durden. Neither can be considered a true representation of masculinity.

Virility and Virtue

Both Fight Club and Casino Royale begin with heroes exhibiting what are popularly conceived as masculine traits: a flair for pain, guns, gambling, technology, swanky bars, fast cars, and stoic cool. One may, of course, observe that the emphasis on uber-masculinity is an attempt to appeal to a specific section of society; but one may also suggest that the emphasis acts to subvert the view of homosexuality as a gender norm. To suggest the latter, one must first accept the definition of homosexuality as a negation of masculinity. Second, one must define masculinity. Connell defines it as anything antagonistic to homosexuality -- but such a definition only provides us with a kind of circularity. Masculinity, as portrayed in the films and pulp fiction of the recent past, have included such types as the John Wayne, the man-with-no-name, the loner, whose moral compass is neither wholly self-centered nor wholly guided by sympathy/empathy.

The nameless narrator of Fight Club may be attempting to understand his masculinity -- and if he suffers from a negation of masculinity it is only in the sense that he suffers from a lack of virility. Tyler Durden appears (with gun in hand -- with holes drilled into the barrel) to revive virility -- but it is, ultimately, a false virility; and Tyler Durden is finally dealt with accordingly. The real virility that the nameless narrator -- the Everyman -- of Fight Club seeks is to be found in the root word of viril: vir, Latin -- man. Vir serves as the base of virtus -- or virtue, and here is where the real search begins to find fruit. Virtue is, according to the ancient Greeks, nothing more than a habit that is good. If manliness is associated with good habits -- vir, virtus -- then it follows that what Fight Club's hero needs is not Tyler Durden and machismo -- but reality and virtue. Tyler frees the hero from his consumer/materialistic slavery, like Moses leads the Hebrews from Egyptian captivity -- but fails to lead the hero to the Promised Land (just as Moses fails to see it himself). Tyler is the springboard from which the hero discovers real masculinity -- neither in materialistic comforts nor in mindless action and violence -- but in true knowledge of self, out of which springs a true awareness of others: the hero escapes isolation and alienation and embarks on a relationship with another real human being -- Marla (at least, this is the ending that the film allows -- which Palahniuk himself confesses is better than his own vision). The ancient Greek maxim etched into the Delphic Temple, "Know Thyself," becomes the foundation upon which masculinity in Fight Club finally comes to rest.

If homosexuality is the negation of masculinity, it is because the homosexual union does not permit fulfillment of the masculine function, which is ultimately an act of regeneration. Fight Club is consumed by a single generation's tension, built up through masturbatory acts. Fight Club is a release from masturbation because it is a release from the fraudulent "self-improvement" exercises of modern civilization: the Better Bodies, the IKEA catalog (depicted as a kind of pornographic magazine in Fincher's film, with the hero looking at it -- as one would a centerfold -- while on the toilet), the meaningless self-defining techniques of the psychotherapists. Each is an attempt to deal with the pain of the built-up tension of a generation steered away from regeneration -- from life. "Don't deal with it the way those dead people do," states Tyler in the film, as he attempts to teach the hero the way to true enlightenment -- that human nature and masculinity are real and must be dealt with. With the embracing of pain and the possibility of heterosexual union, Fight Club resolves the tension at the heart of the narrative: the materialistic comforts must go and real human hetero-normative interaction must replace it, simply because it offers natural fulfillment of the sex function. If homosexuality is the negation of masculinity, heterosexuality is its positive assertion.

And yet heterosexuality in Casino Royale is fantastical, unreal and unconvincing. Ian Fleming's James Bond is a kind of high-stakes, high-rolling international playboy who dabbles in espionage… READ MORE

How to Reference "Representing Masculinities in Casino Royale and Fight Club" Essay in a Bibliography

Related Essays:

Sociological Movie Review on Fight Club Movie Review

Fight Club: A Study of Masculine and Deviant Behavior

Fight Club is the 1999 film directed by David Fincher based on a Chuck Palahniuk novel of the same name. The… read more

Movie Review 3 pages (907 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Literature / Poetry

---

Rules of Project Mayhem in Fight Club Term Paper

Fight Club (Project Mayhem)

Project Mayhem in the novel Fight Club is the continuation of the initial rebellious organization known as "Fight Club." This organization is started in response to… read more

Term Paper 1 pages (341 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Sociology / Society

---

Fight Club Term Paper

Movie Analysis: Fight Club

The movie "Fight Club" is a sincere narration about the "lost generation" of 90's. This new "lost generation" does not belong to hippies, punks, pacifists or… read more

Term Paper 6 pages (1986 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Film / Movies / Television

---

Comparing Two Works Essay

Fight Club & Francis Macomber

Comparison between Fight Club and the Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber

In the film Fight Club, David Fincher constructs the white American male as… read more

Essay 5 pages (1679 words) Sources: 2 Style: MLA Topic: Women / Feminism

---

Fight Club Term Paper

Fight Club written by Chuck Palahniuk in 1996. I have chosen to talk about this particular novel because along with a fascinating plot and a radical look at consumer culture,… read more

Term Paper 5 pages (1431 words) Sources: 3 Style: MLA Topic: Literature / Poetry

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>