Essay on "Feminist Leadership When Professionalism Meets Patriarchy: Practical"

Essay 5 pages (1336 words) Sources: 6

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Feminist Leadership

When Professionalism Meets Patriarchy: Practical and Interpersonal Issues in Female Leadership

The issues of gender inequality and preconceptions are often dealt with in a largely abstract and obtuse manner, and is seen as belonging wholly to the realm of the humanities; they are something for critics, philosophers, and artists of every stripe to dwell on and discuss, but not really relevant to scholarship outside of these fields. Even scholarship in these areas, of course, notes the practical ramifications of the abstract concepts in at least a basic and almost rote fashion: the reduced employment opportunities due to perceptions of lessened ability (or increasing demands as women are expected to be both homemaker and career-oriented, according to some), fewer positions of authority in a variety of social institutions, etc., but they are limited in the extent to which they can explore the practical implications and effects of the patriarchal framework that has been posted to exist in Western culture.

The fact that research with feminist implications and objectives has been so lacking in areas of more direct and specific scientific and/or practical inquiry is itself due largely to the patriarchal framework itself. The framing of a feminist objective or research question is itself seen as an inherently abstract and subjective act in the patriarchal framework, and is automatically seen as subjective and non-scientific as it explicitly defines the perspective of the research. All research has this perspective, of course, but it remains implicit in the dominant framework until attention is called to it precisely because it is the dominant framework.

Empirical, practical research is a growing part of the feminist tradition, however, and points to issues that are both as simple and direct as those identified by feminist literature at large, and also more subtle and personal than mere philosophizing can establish with any sort of certainty. This paper examines the published results of three recent peer-reviewed studies regarding femininity in leadership roles -- how it is perceived, reacted to, and engaged in, and what its effects are for the leaders themselves as well as members of their team and organizations as a whole. Some of the conclusions that this research arrives at seems to uphold conventional wisdom and anecdotal evidence, but the empiric method of achieving these results and the level of detail these research endeavors have produced make them well worthwhile. Ultimately, the research shows that "feminine" leadership traits and methods differ significantly in their operation and influence from traditional leadership methods, and that failing to proactively account for these differences can lead to interpersonal difficulties as well as organizational inefficiencies.

Research

Qualitative research necessarily runs the risk of having less easily defined terms, and in most circumstances less control over variable control. All three of the studies synthesis are primarily qualitative in nature, but significant attempts have been made at variable control and at the presentation of clearly defined variables and terms. This research constitutes a significant inroad for the furtherance of feminist achievement and recognition in empirical studies.

Scott and Brown (2006) determined through a series of connected studies that there are two basic categories types of leadership, agentic leadership and communal leadership. The first study conducted by these authors determined that communal leadership traits -- those which foster greater collaboration and a sense of peer-leadership -- were more accessible when females were leaders than were agentic leadership traits (traits that have a more commanding nature, and the compartmentalize and can create competition), and furthermore that the opposite was the case for male leaders (Scott & Brown 2006). Leaders were able to rate themselves accurately in this way, demonstrating that there is a distinctly different perspective on how leadership should be approached and effectively accomplished among men and women, generally (Scott & Brown 2006). This is far form an inborn and characteristic difference between the sexes, however, and is more likely a symptom of the continued patriarchy in which the leaders feel (often with good reason) they must operate.

It has been demonstrated… READ MORE

How to Reference "Feminist Leadership When Professionalism Meets Patriarchy: Practical" Essay in a Bibliography

Related Essays:

Leadership and You My Personal Research Paper

He is very focused on servant leadership, and on having companies work in a transformational manner in order to be more successful in the marketplace. One of the ways in… read more

Research Paper 4 pages (1319 words) Sources: 4 Style: APA Topic: Leadership / Mentoring

---

Leadership a Mission Statement Term Paper

I can always know that I must weigh the externalities of my behavior and come to a conclusion about which action is morally superior.

Leadership Style

There are a lot… read more

Term Paper 7 pages (2392 words) Sources: 7 Topic: Leadership / Mentoring

---

Leadership Profile Case Study

Leadership Profile One: A Rising Star

Summary of the Situation

Over the holidays, I volunteered at the homeless shelter I have been working with for a number of years. I… read more

Case Study 2 pages (628 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Leadership / Mentoring

---

Leadership Theories and Practical Application as Organizations Research Paper

Leadership Theories and Practical Application

As organizations continue to face challenges and demands from external environments, effective work relationships will no longer be an option but a critical source of… read more

Research Paper 16 pages (5554 words) Sources: 9 Topic: Leadership / Mentoring

---

Leadership Style and Decision-Making Discussion Chapter

Leadership Style and Decision-Making Style

Leadership and Decision Making Style

Leadership matters whether a person works in police department, or academia or in an optometry clinic like me. As a… read more

Discussion Chapter 6 pages (2975 words) Sources: 6 Topic: Leadership / Mentoring

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>