Term Paper on "Evidence in General Reciprocal Discovery"

Term Paper 5 pages (1386 words) Sources: 4 Style: MLA

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Evidence

In general reciprocal discovery is the process by which criminal and/or civil prosecutions and defense aspects of a trial exchange evidence information. The type of evidence information is variable based on the type of trail, i.e. rules are basically less strict in civil cases, than in criminal cases as the burden of proof is also lesser on the part of the prosecution, and the prosecution has more rules of disclosure than the defense. The prosecution must disclose evidence to the defense in a timely manner so that the defense can have every opportunity to shed doubt upon it. The defense has a more limited obligation of evidence exchange as it is allowed to withhold aspects of evidence which violate the defendants right to privacy and/or the fifth amendment but in most states both the defense and the prosecution must disclose a witness docket. Some people have argued for the expansion of these laws and rules to give the defense greater opportunity, especially with regard to the timely release of information that might potentially shed doubt on guilt, or evidence that could demonstrate innocence that was discovered in a criminal investigation. (the Justice Project 1)

Most rules regarding discovery are decided and elaborated on by state and local government with a little bit of help from the federal government, as in landmark supreme court cases that have challenged discovery principles and actions. One such case stresses the timely disclosure of evidence of innocence in a criminal case, on the part of the prosecution. One example of a Supreme Court Ruling on discovery is Brady vs. Maryland in which a criminal prosecution failed to offer accomplice testimony for a defendant that reduced his personal liability in a criminal case to one that would seriously reduce his sentencing possibilities. ("Proposed Codification of Disclosure of Favorable Information under Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure 11 and 16" 93)

The purpose of reciprocal discovery is to ensure that both parties are aware of what is coming at them in a criminal or civil trial and has adequate opportunity to seek information that either disproves or lessens the validity of the evidence brought into court by the apposing council. The major purpose of reciprocal discovery is to maintain a fair trial for the defendant, and to protect him or her from unfair conviction or sentencing. Both parties are given adequate opportunity to respond to and answer any evidence that is brought forth to trial that the defendant may not have been aware of and therefore unable to disclose to his or her attorney. The discovery principals in criminal proceedings also tries to ensure that the prosecution of an offence does not lie solely on any confession tendered by the defendant, but requires that a confession be supported by evidence.

Hall 226) the purpose of this being that confessions can and often are false, many argue as a result of fear on the part of the defendant and in the past the ways of obtaining confessions were not always fair as it is the natural tendency of a criminal investigator to attempt to resolve matters completely, occasionally to a degree that is unfair to the accused.

Penalties for failing to offer reciprocal discovery, on either part is most effectively the ability of the conviction, sentence or findings to be later eliminated in appeals or even in some serious cases to allow the judge to suppress evidence in a first trial or even call a mistrial, ending the current prosecution. Appeal trials, especially in high level cases can seriously undermine any original convictions and therefore must be thought about even before the conviction occurs. All parties are under obligation to disclose information that could be used to support reasonable doubt or that must be countered by other supporting evidence or testimony. In most cases the penalty for failure to disclose is the suppression of such evidence in the trial or in later appeals trials. If evidence is key to conviction its suppression can end in a reversal of the findings of the court and therefore an overturned conviction. (Myers 1277)

The exclusionary rule applies to information and evidence. The rule in… READ MORE

How to Reference "Evidence in General Reciprocal Discovery" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

Physical Education Teacher Burnout and PE Teacher Concerns Literature Review

Aaker (1991, p13) it is the general aim of all researchers not only to discover new information but as much as possible to build on what other people have already… read more

Literature Review 25 pages (8932 words) Sources: 25 Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning

---

Mexico Regional Leader Research Paper

Miguel Sahagun

Mexico: Regional Leader

It was over twenty years ago that Mexico began opening up its trade with the implementation of a number of unilateral policies and its accession… read more

Research Paper 20 pages (7688 words) Sources: 10 Topic: Economics / Finance / Banking

---

Elder Abuse Phenomenon Correlating Relationship to Elder Mortality Term Paper

Elder Abuse Phenomenon Correlating Relationship to Elder Mortality

Elder abuse has received increased scrutiny from the law enforcement and healthcare community in recent years. This increased attention is due in… read more

Term Paper 58 pages (15855 words) Sources: 25 Style: APA Topic: Family / Dating / Marriage

---

Avian Flu Avian Influenza: If H5N1 Term Paper

Avian Flu

Avian Influenza: If H5N1 is the Virus to Fear, Is America Prepared for a Potential Outbreak?

The effects of a bird flu pandemic would dwarf even the devastation… read more

Term Paper 27 pages (8056 words) Sources: 16 Style: APA Topic: Disease / Virus / Disorder / Injury

---

Rise and Fall of the First Civilizations Essay

Ancient Civilizations

One of the earliest human civilizations to exist were the Sumerians, which dwelt in Mesopotamia and began forming large city-states around 3000 BCE. Their government was one of… read more

Essay 3 pages (926 words) Sources: 0 Topic: World History

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>