Term Paper on "Alternative Fuels"

Term Paper 6 pages (2822 words) Sources: 1+

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Ethanol for Fuel

In the famous fairy tale Rumplestiltskin, the miller's daughter is required to spin straw into gold. Only magic can accomplish it. But today, as the price of gasoline goes up and up, most Americans believe that alternative fuels must be developed -- soon -- and are hoping for some similar magic. The reality of the impending fuel crisis was brought home by Hurricane Katrina, which shut down Louisiana oil refineries and drove up the prices. Great hope that bio-fuels will be the solution to the problem has triggered interest and investment in the development of alternative fuels -- particularly, in ethanol. The challenge is to find cost-effective ways to make alcohol out of such renewable resources as corn, soybeans, and sugarcane, cellulose from the stems and leaves of plants, forest cuttings, wood chips, and all the non-food parts of crops that currently get burned or buried. Green Fuel Technologies, for example, in Massachusetts has found a way to create a bio-diesel fuel "by feeding smoke-stack emissions from factories into giant tubes filled with algae" (Popular Science, 2006, p. 60). Instead of straw-into-gold, waste-into-fuel is the goal. And instead of magic, technology is at work.

The purpose of this essay is to explore the progress of ethanol as a fuel derived from renewable crops and especially cellulosic ethanol, which can be produced from agricultural, municipal and forestry waste, corn stalks, sawdust and waste paper. The Department of Energy has commented, "Not quite lead into gold, but maybe more valuable for the U.S. economy, for cutting air pollution, and for reducing dependence on foreign oil" (cited in E: the Environmental Magazine, 2006). Although considerable research has been done on ethanol with hopeful results, much more research is necessary in order to produce enough to significantly reduce U.S. dependence on foreign oil.

The energy bill passed by Congress in 2005 provided "a guaranteed market for 7-1/2 billion gallons by 2012" (Fortune, 2005). This would be ethanol from corn, which has drawn a lot of criticism from various sectors as "welfare" for farm states; however, it's a start. Because the government has mandated more ethanol -- both to replace oil and to supplement it -- the government should fund private research to develop ethanol as a major alternative fuel. As an article in BioCycle puts it, "Now, more than ever, we need to showcase the technologies, research, policies and projects that demonstrate renewable fuels are not only feasible, but economically viable" (BioCycle, 2001). In this essay we will discuss the history of ethanol, its current uses, arguments for and against its serious development, and the progress of building production facilities for ethanol.

History of Ethanol

Ethanol has a longer history than most people realize. Henry Ford's original plan was to run his Model-T on ethanol; however, gasoline proved to be cheaper at that time. During the Arab oil embargo of the 1970s ethanol began to appear at gas stations in the U.S. It was a way to stretch the dwindling supply of gas. Gas became plentiful again during the 1980s, but pollution then became a big issue, and ethanol reappeared "as an environmentally friendly replacement for toxins such as lead and benzene" (Ingebretson, 2001, p. 53).

Ethanol burns more completely because its molecules contain 35 per cent oxygen, which makes it cleaner. It will not threaten water supplies. Ethanol is plain old alcohol, nothing more; in fact, to avoid federal and state alcoholic beverages taxes, producers must make it undrinkable by adding 5% petroleum. Thus, refineries are really high-tech stills. When ethanol is made from corn, the corn ground into meal and mixed with water to form a mash. After about two days, the mash becomes "beer." Then it goes through the still, and 200-proof alcohol is the result. Solid wastes left over are turned into animal feed, and the CO-2 that comes from the fermenting process is used for carbonation of soft drinks (Imbretson, 2001).

In the mid-1970s Brazil instituted a large-scale ethanol program. Their ethanol is taken from sugarcane, and used either pure or blended with gas. In the 1970s Brazil was heavily dependent on fossil fuels, and they were concerned about national sovereignty. OPEC's decrease in oil production had driven up prices; meanwhile, sugar industrialists were at the point of bankruptcy. With sugar prices so low, it made sense to turn sugarcane into ethanol (Oliveira, Vaughan & Rykiel, 2005). Now, more than 50% of Brazil's vehicles run on ethanol.

Oliveira, Vaughan, and Rykiel (2005) report that amendments to the Clean Air Act of 1990 led legislators to consider fuels for the first time as a way to reduce pollution. The amendments called for controlling carbon monoxide and improving gasoline by increasing the oxygen content. Because ethanol oxygenates, it became a major fuel component. Most ethanol produced in the United States (90%) comes from corn. Pure ethanol is rarely used. It is nearly always mixed with gas. The most popular blend is called E85 with 15% gasoline and 85% ethanol.

Current Uses of Ethanol

Nebraska is a good example of increased ethanol production and use. In Nebraska ethanol use was about 24 per cent in 1999 with one person in four or five choosing an ethanol blend, but the number has increased to over 40% as a result of "a concerted and coordinated effort to promote ethanol-blended gasoline" (Gardner, 2003, p. 42). An advertising campaign in Nebraska came about because although people in the state believed ethanol was good for farmers, reduced air pollution, was good for the economy, and reduced dependence on foreign oil, when they got to the pump, they weren't actually buying it. The campaign to get them to buy ethanol was "built around making the right choice for fuel and the right choice for Nebraska" (cited in Gardner, 2003, p. 43).

As of 2001, only about one million vehicles used alternative fuel -- less than 1% of the 200 million vehicles on U.S. roads. Deierlein (2001) states, "Most industry veterans believe this is because alternative-fueled vehicles cost more, weigh more, have a smaller range and fewer opportunities to refuel, require training and must be fueled twice because they require two different fuels" (p. 62).

An article in Automotive Industries echoes the concern that ethanol use is not as high as it should be; however, it blames the ethanol industry for not truly being "behind the use of the substance as a fuel which subsequently has driven up the price of ethanol" (Automotive Industries, 2003, p. 52). Ethanol companies get a higher price for ethanol when it is used as an oxygenate blend with gasoline. Hence, they are more interested in blending it than with using it pure. The article also explains that ethanol cannot come into contact with aluminum because it is corrosive and although it doesn't look any different than gas, it has to be "dispensed differently and requires a different pump" (p. 53). Because of this, it costs more, and this makes gas stations hesitant to invest in the needed equipment.

Manufacturers are now turning out "flex-fuel" vehicles that can run on gas or an E85 blend. However, not many of these flex-fuel cars are actually operated using ethanol. It is still hard to find it. Everyone agrees that ethanol is cleaner and more efficient to produce than gas. But David Friedman, research director of the Union of Concerned Scientists' Clean Vehicles Program, argues that cellulosic ethanol is "dramatically more efficient than corn ethanol" (cited in E: the Environmental Magazine, 2005, p. 10). Cellulosic ethanol is being produced throughout the country in small quantities using "everything from brewery waste to cheese whey." Iogen Corporation in Canada is making it from wheat straw and selling it commercially. But a spokesperson from Renewable Fuels Association, an ethanol lobbying group, says, "Right now cellulosic is an inefficient technology. Funding into additional research is needed."

Rather than using food crops, cellulosic ethanol is made from waste products. The Department of Energy says that 375 million gallons of gasoline per day cannot be replaced with agricultural wastes alone. But another potential source for ethanol is switchgrass, a native prairie grass that needs very little fertilizer, is drought resistant, and wouldn't take up space where food crops need to be planted. Nathaniel Greene, a senior policy analyst at the Natural Resources Defense Council, argues that if we don't get beyond corn ethanol, "we won't be able to make a big dent in oil consumption" (cited in E: the Environmental Magazine, 2005, p. 10). Cellulosic ethanol is an area where the government ought to be investing research monies.

Arguments for and against Ethanol as a Major Alternative Fuel

The transition from petroleum to renewable alternative fuels could produce a great and positive impact on the world's economy. R. James Woolsy, CIA Director, said in Foreign Affairs: "If the hundreds of billions of dollars that now flow into a few coffers in a few nations were to flow instead to the millions of people who till the world's fields, most countries… READ MORE

How to Reference "Alternative Fuels" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

Alternative Fuels Essay

Alternative Fuels

Energy policy today should be focused on the development of alternative fuel sources. The case has never been more compelling. Peak oil occurred in 2006, meaning that oil… read more

Essay 2 pages (691 words) Sources: 4 Topic: Energy / Power

---

Alternative Fuels the Key to the Future Term Paper

Alternative Fuels

THE KEY to the FUTURE of the PLANET

Over the past ten years or so, the American government and the public have increased their awareness of the problems… read more

Term Paper 3 pages (973 words) Sources: 3 Style: APA Topic: Energy / Power

---

Alternative Fuel Vehicles Research Proposal

Alternative Fuel Vehicles

Alternative fueled vehicles use forms of energy other than conventional and traditional gasoline and diesel fuel. Included in those alternative forms of fuel are fuels such as… read more

Research Proposal 20 pages (5345 words) Sources: 8 Style: APA Topic: Transportation / Mass Transit

---

Alternative Fuel for Lotus Alternative Fuel Assessment Term Paper

Alternative Fuel for Lotus

ALTERNATIVE FUEL ASSESSMENT for LOTUS CAR RENTAL

In the past few decades, citizens, environmentalists and government officials alike have become increasingly aware of the threatening approach… read more

Term Paper 7 pages (2145 words) Sources: 6 Style: APA Topic: Energy / Power

---

Alternative Fuels for Commercial Aviation Thesis

alternative fuels as well as the presently available fuels and those which are still in the developmental phases. There has been an increase in concern over degradation of the environment… read more

Thesis 9 pages (2489 words) Sources: 6 Style: APA Topic: Energy / Power

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>