Term Paper on "Enemy of Great, Jim Collins Critiques"

Term Paper 5 pages (1450 words) Sources: 1 Style: MLA

[EXCERPT] . . . .

enemy of great," Jim Collins critiques the culture of mediocrity in the bestselling Good to Great. Collins' study of effective organizational management presents case studies and quantitative data to illustrate why and how some companies succeed, becoming the best in their field. Greatness comes from a combination of factors, according to Collins. Companies transition from being good to being great in three basic stages: amassing the right team of disciplined people; creating a disciplined organizational culture; and acting in systematic and disciplined ways. The repeated appearance of the word 'discipline' in each of these stages is no accident, for Collins is a firm believer in pragmatism over miracles; hard work over charisma or luck. The author also sets out to offer managerial staff guidelines with which to craft an organizational culture that cultivates greatness, and to point out potential pitfalls that prevent organizations from reaching their highest potential.

Some of the findings of Collins' research are summarized on page 10. CEOs, for example, are rarely "celebrity leaders" in good-to-great companies and most great organizations cull their CEOs from inside. Technology can assist the transformation from good to great but technology alone cannot cause such a transformation. Most significantly, Collins found that becoming great is rarely a revolution; rather, becoming great is a long-term and steady process based on realistic yet rigorous methods. Interestingly, greatness rarely depends on luck or even fortunate circumstances but instead, on the conscious decision to take disciplined action. With such a strong emphasis on discipline, Collins takes the magic out of corporate empire-building and replaces myth with common sense and evidence-based results.

Good to Great is divided into nine chapters plus an epilogue, appendixes, and reference notes. The first chapter: "Good is the Enemy of Great," outlines the motivations behind Collins' undertakings, the research methodologies, and the overall findings. The author admits that he was motivated mainly by curiosity and personal interest in the transformation of good companies into great organizations. Comparing the good-to-great companies with a control group enabled the author to point out exactly which factors distinguished the greats from the rest. Collins selected comparison groups in the same industries, "with the same opportunities and similar resources at the time of transition," (p. 8). Additionally, the author examined a handful of organizations that made a short-term leap to greatness but failed in the long-term to maintain their supremacy. Evidence was based on peer-reviewed articles, interviews, and quantitative financial data. Finally, Collins shows why his research is important by claiming that his findings can be broadly applied to all areas of human endeavor with the goal of overcoming mediocrity.

Chapter 2 describes the qualities of "Level 5 Leadership." Level 5 leaders help transform good companies into great ones through immense personal sacrifice and self-discipline, according to Collins. A Level 5 leader is "self-effacing" and "their ambition is first and foremost for the institution, not themselves," (p. 21). Collins also describes Level 5 leadership as being a "paradoxical blend of personal humility and professional will," (p. 20). Level 5 leaders resist blaming others for their failures and instead look to ways they can personally improve their organization's chances.

The author's leadership pyramid and description of the levels of leadership on page 20 may be arbitrary if not juvenile but nevertheless illustrates the core differences between managers who are merely effective and those who lead their organizations to ultimate success. Humility plus determination seems to be the magical formula for the development of greatness. To illustrate the case, Collins compares the leaders of two rival paper companies, Kimberly-Clark and Scott. The CEO of Kimberly-Clark was a mild-mannered man who seemed barely qualified for the pressures of leadership. Darwin Smith was known for his shyness, not his schmoozing with powered individuals. Collins attributes his transforming of Kimberly-Clark into an industry giant at least in part to Smith's Level 5-style leadership. The author contrasts the Clark story with Kimberly-Clark's competitor Scott Paper. Scott CEO Al Dunlap was "a man cut from a very different cloth than Darwin Smith," according to Collins, and unlike Smith, Dunlap reveled in his on personal glory and compared himself to Rambo (p. 29). Collins compares Dunlap to the notorious Lee Iacocca.

In Chapter 3, Collins continues to discuss the importance of people by focusing on teams and team management. In "First Who...Then What," Collins criticizes the "genius… READ MORE

How to Reference "Enemy of Great, Jim Collins Critiques" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

Jim Collins Research Paper

Jim Collins is an American business consultant who provides lecturer on the subject of company growth and sustained progress. In 1992, he won the 'Distinguished Teachers Award' while working as… read more

Research Paper 7 pages (2158 words) Sources: 5 Topic: Business / Corporations / E-commerce

---

Jim Collins' 'Good to Great' an Analysis Article Critique

The point being passed across here is that leaders of great companies should be capable of simplifying complicated concepts and ideas into one main idea that will act as a… read more

Article Critique 2 pages (676 words) Sources: 1 Topic: Business / Corporations / E-commerce

---

Adage, Good Is the Enemy of Great Term Paper

adage, "Good is the enemy of great," (Collins, 2001, p. 1). Good to Great is written for those who want to achieve greatness. Described as a "researcher and management guru,"… read more

Term Paper 7 pages (2220 words) Sources: 5 Topic: Literature / Poetry

---

Jim Collins Level 5 Leadership Term Paper

Jim Collins

Level 5 Leadership: Which is harder to cultivate within yourself: humility or will?

Personal humility and professional will are both excellent characters in a leader. In fact Jim… read more

Term Paper 8 pages (2719 words) Sources: 3 Topic: Leadership / Mentoring

---

Great Expectations Term Paper

Great Expectations

Charles Dickens' novel "Great Expectations" is a critique of Victorian culture, rather than an affirmation Victorian Britain social culture. Dickens carefully includes all the social classes in his… read more

Term Paper 1 pages (396 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Literature / Poetry

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>