Book Review on "Elliot Sclar's Influential Book, You"

Book Review 4 pages (1185 words) Sources: 0

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Elliot Sclar's influential book, You Don't Always Get What You Pay For: The Economics of Privatization examines the process of privatization. In a struggling economy it has become fashionable for communities to consider the privatization of what have been historically public services in an effort to economize and streamline governmental operations

Sclar in his book examines the advantages and disadvantages and does so through the use of some strongly supported data but his conclusions, in the end, may be flawed.

In his book, Sclar essentially comes to two conclusions. First, he argues that the result of privatization is not greater and more efficient production. On occasion, it might be successful but, on the whole, there is little benefit to the process. Second, Sclar takes issue with economists who view privatization as the cure for all governmental ills and argues that such economists are narrow minded in their approach to possible solutions and suggesting a solution that, in reality, is not.

In his book, Sclar examines the popular belief that anything operated by a government is typified by waste and inefficiency and attempts to downplay the idea that the solution is allowing more private businesses to take over public functions. Sclar argues, to the contrary, that privatization has costs, both socially and economically, that are often overlooked in the rush to get governments out of the process.

The movement toward privatization, Sclar argues, is the result of an overall disillusionment with government. This disillusionment began in both Canada and the United States in the years following the Vietnam War and Watergate when the public began to view governments as being largely ineffective and corrupt. The public's disillusionment was reinforced by the election of politicians such as Ronald Reagan in the United States and Brian Mulroney in Canada who openly advocated reducing the size of governments and spearheaded the movement toward privatization of services that were the province of governments.

Sclar's view of successful privatization is highly simplistic in that his total standard is whether or not the process results in reducing the costs of production. In this regard, Sclar does not dismiss privatization as a total failure. In his book he notes a number of highly successful examples but notes that the areas where privatization has been a success are where the work is a combination of the work being done by a private firm with strict public supervision. Additionally, Sclar argues that the successful privatization programs work best where the services being privatized utilize lower-skilled labor. The reason for this, Sclar argues, is that the discrepancy between what governments traditionally pay such employees is much higher, in both benefits and salary, than private employers pay and that, as a result, there is a much larger marginal value for private firms to get involved. As the skill level increases for the job, the salary differences between what private firms offer and what governments pay is minimized. Accountants and lawyers working for the government are paid on an almost equal basis with the private sector. As a result, the privatization of such services provides governments with much less financial advantage.

Although Sclar agrees that the privatization of government services involving low skilled labor makes economic sense he points out that the economic gain is offset by the social costs involved. The loss of well-paying, low-skilled jobs due to privatization deprives individuals seeking such employment with the opportunity of earning a living wage. Because private firms traditionally pay such workers at a level barely above minimum wage the savings for the private firm are considerable… READ MORE

How to Reference "Elliot Sclar's Influential Book, You" Book Review in a Bibliography

Related Book Reviews:

Don't Ask, Don't Tell Policy in the Military Term Paper

ask Don't tell Policy in the Military"

"Don't ask, don't tell"

History of gay individuals in the military and the starting point for "Don't ask, don't tell"

Instances when the… read more

Term Paper 8 pages (2136 words) Sources: 8 Topic: Sexuality / Gender

---

Book Term Paper

Alison Pearson's I Don't Know How She Does It

In her comic novel I Don't Know How She Does It, journalist Alison Pearson provides readers with the epitome of modern… read more

Term Paper 2 pages (747 words) Sources: 1 Topic: Literature / Poetry

---

Gays in the Military: Don't Ask, Don't Tell Essay

Don't ask don't tell' policy of the United States military was implemented in 1993 to keep the military from openly pursuing gay, lesbian, and bisexual members and applicants that were… read more

Essay 2 pages (662 words) Sources: 1 Topic: Sexuality / Gender

---

Chinua Achebe's 1958 Novel Things Fall Apart Essay

Chinua Achebe's 1958 novel "Things Fall Apart" provides readers with an intriguing account involving concepts like African cultural values, colonialism, and exaggerated self-respect. The writer does a great job describing… read more

Essay 6 pages (1656 words) Sources: 5 Topic: Literature / Poetry

---

James C. Peterson's Why Don't We Listen Book Review

James C. Peterson's Why Don't We Listen Better? Communicating and Connecting in Relationships

"Hey, that's not what I meant!" Using James C. Peterson's 'talker-listener' card to engage in productive dialogue… read more

Book Review 6 pages (1853 words) Sources: 1 Topic: Religion / God / Theology

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>