Essay on "Conflict of Laws"

Essay 9 pages (2854 words) Sources: 0 Style: APA

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Domicile is the method by which the courts in the United States connect a person to a particular place for purposes of litigation. Generally, domicile will become an issue by virtue of two legal determinations: 1) it will appear as a result of a question of jurisdiction, that is, whether or not a defendant is domiciled within a particular location for purposes of exercising jurisdiction over the person; 2) in determining what the choice of law might be between the litigants. Simply, the issue is determined by whether or not the plaintiff and defendant each possess significant contacts with the particular jurisdiction to form a reasonable basis for applying said jurisdiction's laws.

Regardless whether the issue of domicile is a matter of jurisdiction or significant contacts, analyzing the appropriateness of domicile will be the same. The issue will come down to making a decision whether the domicile is one of origin, choice, or by operation of law. Domicile of origin is assigned to every U.S. citizen at the time of his or her birth and is based upon the domicile of one's parent. Domicile of choice is acquired by an individual's physical presence in a particular jurisdiction and intent to remain in said jurisdiction. Unless both of these elements are present at the same time, domicile remains in one's prior domicile. Domicile by operation of law is a more complicated matter. This type of domicile is reserved for those who historically were unable to establish domicile on their own such wives, minors, and persons under a disability.

Chapter 2

Jurisdiction of Courts

Jurisdiction is the authority of a court to render decisions relative to a person's legal status, personal interests, or property rights. In determining the jurisdictional authority of a court is based on a number of factors including the a party's contacts with the jurisdiction, the statutory authority of the jurisdiction, and the receipt of proper notice and the opportunity to be heard.

There are essentially three types of jurisdiction. The first type of jurisdiction is described as in personam jurisdiction and it involves the power of the court to determine the personal rights and duties of the parties and then, subsequently, having the power to enforce those duties and rights against the person and the person's property. The second form of jurisdiction is in rem jurisdiction. Distinguished from in personam jurisdiction, in rem jurisdiction applies only to a particular piece of property and not as to any individual or individuals. The involved property must be within the jurisdiction limits of the courts but the court's decision is applicable to the entire world. The final type of jurisdiction is quasi-in rem jurisdiction. This type of jurisdiction involves a person's rights in a particular piece of property but the court's decisions in such decision are not applicable against the entire world.

Chapter 3

Choice of Law

Choice of law occurs when a party is able to establish contacts with more than one jurisdiction sufficient enough to call into question which law should be applied in any pending litigation. This situation has become more common as our society becomes more mobile and businesses have established themselves in multiple jurisdictions. In such cases, the courts are placed in a position of determining which jurisdiction's laws will apply and, interestingly, whether the full range of laws should apply or only a portion of the laws.

Chapter Four

Approaches to Choice of Law

Choice of law is a procedural stage in litigation which refers to what jurisdiction's laws will be applied in the course of the case. The determination is whether the forum state's laws, that is, the state in which the action is filed, or whether the law of another state which has an interest in the outcome of the state will be applied. Generally, the choices are between the state where the action is filed and the state where the cause of action arose. In most situations, the procedural rules of the state where the action is filed will be utilized in conducting the case while the substantive laws of the state where the cause of action arose will be used. In order for a case to be heard in any state there is an absolute requirement that there must be some connection between the state and the cause of action or the parties.

There are three basic types of approaches to choice of law: the traditional vested interest doctrine; the various interest and policy analysis; and, the most significant relationship approach. The vested interest approach is based on the belief that a state should have the right to rule on matters that occur within its borders while the interest and policy approach attempts to balance the relative interests of the litigants and the state where the action is filed. Finally, the most significant relationship theory examines which state has the most contacts with the litigation. Factors considered include the place of the injury, place of the conduct causing the injury, residence or place of business of the parties, and the place where the parties have had the most contact.

Chapter Five

Choices of Law -- Specific Substantive Areas

The choice of law may be dependent on the nature of the cause of action. There is no uniform approach to making a determination as to which law will be applied in any given type of case and the specific approach varies depending on the nature of the case.

Within specific substantive areas there may be some variation in the method used to determine which law to apply. Certain tort actions such as wrongful death, dram shop actions, and workers compensation cases are governed primarily by statute and not the common law and, therefore, particular attention must be paid by litigants to the language of the statute in the state where one is contemplating filing the action. Traditionally, the choice of law in tort actions is based on the significant relationship test. As already indicated, this standard can vary depending on the nature of the tort.

In contract actions the courts must pay deference to the law chosen by the parties. In many cases the contract document will set forth the parties' choice of the law that they prefer. In cases where this is not the case the significant relationship test is again applied. The significant relationship standards in contract cases, however, differ from those used in tort cases. In contract cases the significant standards include the place of contracting, the place where the negotiations for the contract occurred, the location where the contract was expected to be performed, the location of the subject matter of the contract, and the domicile or place of incorporation of the businesses.

Chapter Six

Traditional Defenses

There are a number of defenses that serve to defeat the application of traditional conflict rules. These defenses are based on public policy, penal laws, or revenue laws. In denying the filing of causes of action based on a violation of public policy the basic issue is whether the content of the foreign law when compared with public policy of the reviewing court is seriously deficient in quality. What occurs in this situation is that the forum state is sitting in judgment over the wisdom and fairness of the foreign law. Needless to say, the public policy limitation is used very infrequently by the courts.

Penal and Revenue defenses are also used infrequently as they involve the application of foreign laws that deal with attempts by governmental agencies and the courts are reluctant to involve themselves in such causes of actions. In these type of cases the courts will generally act to enforce judgments by government agencies but not involve themselves in government attempts to enforce the underlying claims.

In most conflict of law cases, the courts, when applying foreign law, will apply the substantive laws of such jurisdiction but apply the procedural laws of the forum state. Substantive law addresses the issues that materially affect the outcome of the case while procedural laws are those that dictate the rules of how the litigation will be conducted.

Chapter Seven

Constitutional Limitations

There are a variety of considerations in regard to the constitutional application of the choice of laws. The application of the Fourteenth Amendment and its reliance on Due Process has had a significant impact on the conflict of laws area. The courts for the most part have adopted a lenient position on due process and have allowed minimal contacts to be sufficient for the filing of an action. At the same time, however, the courts have warned against applying a forum law in situations where the state has no contacts with the transaction or parties involved in the action.

The Full Faith and Credit Clause has caused some difficulties in this area. The determination factor in such cases is whether or not a state has a real policy issue interest in applying its own laws as opposed to the laws of another state. As the purpose of the Clause is… READ MORE

How to Reference "Conflict of Laws" Essay in a Bibliography

Related Essays:

Corporate Civil Procedure and Constitutional Law Term Paper

Gilbert Law Summaries: Constitutional Law by Jesse Choper

The United States Constitution is the foremost legal authority for laws created in the United States. Though the Constitution is a federal… read more

Term Paper 32 pages (10293 words) Sources: 1 Topic: Law / Legal / Jurisprudence

---

Law Versus Justice Term Paper

Law vs. Justice

Justice is defined (Dictionary.com 2005) as conformity to moral rightness in action or attitude, the upholding of what is just, especially fair treatment and due reward. Law,… read more

Term Paper 7 pages (2191 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Law / Legal / Jurisprudence

---

Collaborative Methods for Conflict Resolution Case of Marriage in India Law Case Study

Conflict

Law and Norms: Regulators in Conflict and Coordination

A recent court ruling in Madras High Court of India has complex and far-reaching implications. In the seemingly modest case of… read more

Case Study 2 pages (637 words) Sources: 3 Topic: Law / Legal / Jurisprudence

---

Effects of World Trade Organizations Dispute Settlement System on International Law Research Paper

WTO Law

WTO and International Law Qs

The World Trade Organization impacts international law in both direct and indirect manners, and strangely it provides strength to international law even in… read more

Research Paper 3 pages (865 words) Sources: 5 Style: Chicago Topic: Law / Legal / Jurisprudence

---

Evolution of Commercial Law From the 18th Century to the Current International E-Commerce Era Research Paper

evolution of commercial law from the eighteenth century to the current international e-commerce era, with an eye towards specific crises and responses that led to formation of the current system… read more

Research Paper 15 pages (4491 words) Sources: 11 Topic: Law / Legal / Jurisprudence

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>