Term Paper on "Morality and the Need to Disobey the Law"

Term Paper 4 pages (1405 words) Sources: 1+

[EXCERPT] . . . .

DISOBEYING the LAW have always been against nuclear empowerment of countries. After what happened to people in variety of nuclear-related incidents, I feel that countries have an obligation toward their people to abandon further plans in this connection. We can imagine the horrors and the havoc that nuclear devices would create if a war breaks out between two nuclear powers. For this reason when one Wednesday, my friend Susan, told me that there was a protest going on against nuclear enrichment, I was quick to tell her to sign me up for the demonstration. It was a few minutes later that she confessed that demonstrators are planning to trespass the nuclear power plan building.

Trespassing is against the law and trespassing government property can be downright criminal. But I wanted to support the cause and felt if the only way to make an impact was by doing something as drastic as breaking in, then I was ready. Susan was not happy with my decision. Though she is as huge a supporter of nuclear disarmament as I am, still she felt that such demonstrations indicated a clear disobedience of law. This resulted in a long argument in which my point was that it was sometimes morally and ethically correct to disobey the law. Susan obviously did not agree with what appeared to her rather radical way of thinking but with further arguments, she was finally convinced that there are situations where our moral and ethical duty to disobey takes precedence over our duty to obey the law.

The duty to obey the law has been so firmly engrained in our consciousness that anything against this automatically elicits a negative response. But when carefully studied, it becomes quite clear that duty to obey the law might not always be connected with our moral duties in other areas. We all understand that nuclear enrichment is a great cause of concern. In case of a war between two nations with nuclear power, the results would not only be disastrous, they will also be felt for ages. Do we want our children to suffer? Don't we want them to grow up in a healthy unthreatening environment? Are we concerned about their safety and future? What about the abnormalities that will occur in some children due to nuclear elements in the air? Is the state not disobeying its duty to serve the people by developing dangerous devices and weapons?

All these questions must be carefully considered. These questions and many like them indicate clearly that there are times when the political authority that wants us to obey the law must not only be disobeyed but must also be taught what is correct and what is not. In other words, there comes a time when one has to put his foot down in the face of law. Now let us see how philosophers and thinkers have discussed the subject. W.D. Ross feels that the duty to obey the law is grounded in the concept of exchange of goods. As we obey the law, we receive benefits in return. Or rather since we receive certain benefits, we should obey the law as a sign of gratitude. He contends:

Thus... The duty of obeying the laws of one's country arises partly (as Socrates contends in the Crito) from the duty of gratitude for the benefits one has received from it; partly from the implicit promise to obey which seems to be involved in permanent residence in a country whose laws we know we are expected to obey, and still more clearly involved when we ourselves invoke the protection of its laws...; and partly (if we are fortunate in our country) from the fact that its laws are potent instruments for the general good. (Ross 1930, p. 27f.).

The few important concepts emerging from Ross's argument include such noble thoughts as benefits, gratitude, implicit promise and potent instruments. But while this is generally true, it may not be so valid in cases such as the one described above. True, we should be grateful to the state but what if the same state is hurting our rights. As a citizen of this country, I have a right to expect certain goods such as… READ MORE

How to Reference "Morality and the Need to Disobey the Law" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

Is International Law Really Law? Term Paper

Enforcement of International Law

The argument against international law

International law that is defined as the body of law that is used to effectively govern the legal relationship among or… read more

Term Paper 7 pages (1902 words) Sources: 5 Topic: Law / Legal / Jurisprudence

---

Ethical and Moral Behavior Term Paper

ethical and moral behavior and why such behaviors are necessary in the enforcement of the rules of the criminal justice system

Relationships of Criminal justice system, ethics and morality

The… read more

Term Paper 10 pages (4020 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Ethics / Morality

---

MLK Jr. On Morality, Utilitarianism, Socrates Martin Essay

MLK Jr. On Morality, Utilitarianism, Socrates

Martin Luther King Jr.'s Morality, Utilitarianism, and Socrates

Martin Luther King, Jr. was perhaps the most prominent civil rights activist in U.S. history. His… read more

Essay 2 pages (721 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Ethics / Morality

---

Law and Social Justice Term Paper

Social Justice -- Kantian Paradigm

The United States Supreme Court made a judgment in 1976 to allow the fifty states to reinstate capital punishment if they wish to. The state… read more

Term Paper 11 pages (3891 words) Sources: 6 Style: MLA Topic: Law / Legal / Jurisprudence

---

Morality and the Professional Life Values at Work Research Paper

resolution of problems involving conflicting moral and nonmoral values presents a real dilemma to the individual tasked with solving such a case. It is therefore critical that an appropriate decision-making… read more

Research Paper 4 pages (1035 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Career / Labor / Human Resources

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>