Essay on "Under What Circumstances if Any Is it Appropriate to Depart From the Rule of Law"

Essay 10 pages (3689 words) Sources: 15 Style: Harvard

[EXCERPT] . . . .

depart from the rule of law?

Rule of Law

As Waldron (2009) emphasizes, the rule of law is considered to be "… one of the most important political ideals of our time."

He provides the following example of the rule of law in an international setting.

As a November 2007 New York Times editorial states, when President Musharaff of Pakistan fired the chief justice of the Supreme Court of Pakistan and had him placed under house arrest, Musharaff's actions were seen around the world as a crisis of the Rule of Law. Law societies and bar associations all over the world protested and, in Pakistan itself, thousands of judges and lawyers demonstrated in the streets and hundreds of them were beaten and arrested.

The above stresses the universal acceptance of the rule of law. The following essay is intended to address the question; under what circumstances is it appropriate to deviate from the rule of law? It will be suggested in this paper that while the rule of law cannot be deviated from in principle it can be questioned and interrogated. There are certain circumstances, such as issues relating to social security and human rights where the rule of law may not live up to its core principles and tenets of equality and the ethos of fairness and justice that constitutes the foundation of the rule of law.

In order to discuss possible deviations from this concept one first has to understand the context as well as fundamental concepts of the rule of law both in theory and praxis. The following section will therefore provide an overview of the rule of law.

2. The Rule of Law<br />

As a number of studies of this subject point out, the rule of law does not have a precise definition. The meaning of this term can vary considerably between different cultures and different legal structures and traditions. In essence, it is understood as a "… legal-political regime under which the law restrains the government by promoting certain liberties and creating order and predictability regarding how a country functions."

At a very fundamental level it is "… a system that attempts to protect the rights of citizens from arbitrary and abusive use of government power."

The rule of law therefore supersedes governmental or other interest groups and is intended to maintain a system of unbiased and even-handed justice.

The rule of law is also seen as an essential and fundamental part of Western Democracy. The history of the rule of law can be traced back to the writings of Plato and Aristotle, which were extremely influential in the development of Western civilization and the democratic ideal. As Aristotle stated more than two thousand years ago; "The rule of law is better than that of any individual."

This refers to the principle of protection from abusive power through this concept. The law becomes the guiding principle for decision and actions in the society, which transcends parties and power groups. This point is emphasized in one study as follows: "The King himself ought not to be subject to man, but subject to God and the law, because the law makes him King."

This is an aspect that cannot be overemphasized. Another study on this subject clearly and succinctly summarizes this essential point.

The rule of law first of all implies that law is applied impersonally. That is, the law is not created in order to satisfy the preferences of any individuals. The impersonal nature of the rule of law creates a seal between the application of political and legal power (which is necessarily in the hands of persons in positions of leadership) and the justification of the use of that power (which is assigned to the law itself). This is perhaps the most important aspect of the rule of law as it effectively bars the arbitrary use of power.

The above is quoted at length as it underlines an essential point. The primary function of the rule of law is to ensure that the use of power is " bound" or limited by the law which has no bias or preference. This means that the power of office or economic or political power cannot be used to attain private and personal ends which exceed the law. This leads to the following important implication of the rule of law: "If the rule of law is perfectly applied, it is not possible for political action to be a result of personal preferences."

More specifically the rule of law can be broken down or categorized into certain central elements. These are;

The supremacy of law -- which implies that both the individual and the government are subject to the law.

The concept of justice - which emphasizes interpersonal adjudication, law based on standards and the importance of procedures.

Restrictions on the exercise of discretionary power.

The doctrine of judicial precedent.

An independent judiciary.

The exercise by Parliament of the legislative power and restrictions on exercise of legislative power by the executive.

An underlying moral basis for all law.

There are also a number of important elements that are necessary for the institution and functioning of the rule of law. These include the cardinal point made above that laws transcend the individuals and government officials; these laws must be published and they must be clear and not contradictory.

Furthermore, the rule of law necessitates that,

Laws must be prospective in nature so that the effect of the law may only take place after the law has been passed. For example, the court cannot convict a person of a crime committed before a criminal statute prohibiting the conduct was passed. "

An important element of the rule of law is the laws should be able to be revised and altered if change is necessitated by social or political events or circumstances. This is a point that will be expanded on the following section on the possible deviations from the rule of law.

The above also refers to a central concern in the application of the rule of law. With the formalization of the law these laws may become entrenched and hidebound over time. Furthermore, due to social or political circumstances some laws may take precedence over others, with the result that the legal system may become too rigid and even biased; and this in turn may have a detrimental effect on aspects such as human rights in the society.

The above discussion leads to the central principles that reflect the spirit of the rule of law. The first principle from an article by the Rule of Law Institute of Australia refers to the aforementioned point that government should be subject to and under the law. In other words,"… the law should apply to and be observed by government and its agencies, those given power in the community, just as it apply to the ordinary citizen."

The second principle is that those who administer the law, such as judges and solicitors should be unbiased and uninfluenced by external factors such as their role, position or their duties. Thirdly, there should be "… ready access to the courts of law for those who seek legal remedy and relief."

The fourth principle is that the laws of the land should be "…certain, general and equal in its operation."

In terms of conceptualization and theory, the rule of law can be understood form two perspectives; this refers to the materialist and idealist stances. The idealist view sees the rule of laws as an abstract concept that must be adhered to, while from the materialist point-of-view the rule of law is a result of the progress of civilized development; "…the materialists would say it is a concept that has arisen into our consciousness, due to humanity's achievement of the material world with technology."

Both these perspectives are important for a full understanding of the development of the rule of law in our contemporary society.

A distinction should also be made between the rule by law and the rule of law. The rule of law should not be reduced to or understood as the rule by law. The rule of law has greater depth and meaning than just the application of laws. "The rule of law is not the systematic and constant application of laws -- that is rule by law, not the rule of law…"

Furthermore, predictability is a central and important aspect of the rule of law. This is linked to the concept of legal and societal stability and open access to the law by everyone. In this regard, …a norm cannot be regarded as a 'law' unless it is formulated with sufficient precision to enable the citizen to regulate his conduct: he must be able - if need be with appropriate advice - to foresee, to a degree that is reasonable in the circumstances, the consequences which a given action may entail.

3. Deviations from the Rule of Law

In essence, and in principle, there should not be any deviation or abrogation… READ MORE

How to Reference "Under What Circumstances if Any Is it Appropriate to Depart From the Rule of Law" Essay in a Bibliography

Related Essays:

Employment Law Is Made Up a Great Research Paper

Employment law is made up a great many common law rulings, statutes, administrative rules and legislation. Its governance falls under the umbrella of both federal and state statutes, as well… read more

Research Paper 9 pages (3073 words) Sources: 5 Topic: Career / Labor / Human Resources

---

Korematsu Rasul Al Odah and Hamdi Cases Term Paper

Korematsu, Rasul, Al Odah, And Hamdi Terrorist and War Cases

Since the September 11 terrorist attacks in 2001, the Constitution of the United States has come under considerable scrutiny both… read more

Term Paper 6 pages (2073 words) Sources: 3 Style: APA Topic: Law / Legal / Jurisprudence

---

Counterterrorism the Future of Counterterrorism Policies: Examining Literature Review

Counterterrorism

The Future of Counterterrorism Policies:

Examining Partnerships

between

Special Operations Forces

Law Enforcement Agencies

The terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001 will never be forgotten by the millions of… read more

Literature Review 14 pages (4165 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Terrorism / Extremism / Radicalization

---

Art Violence and Social Engagement in Colombia Research Proposal

Colombia is the third-largest recipient of military aid from the United States and is at a critical juncture in its turbulent history. More than three million people have been displaced… read more

Research Proposal 58 pages (19788 words) Sources: 35 Style: Chicago Topic: Latin America / Mexico / Caribbean

---

Teacher Motivation Research Proposal

Teaching is one of the professions that many and indeed probably even most people enter with a large measure of idealism. They seek out education as a profession not for… read more

Research Proposal 64 pages (17626 words) Sources: 32 Topic: Education / Teaching / Learning

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>