Term Paper on "Deterrent Effects of the Death Penalty"

Term Paper 3 pages (1156 words) Sources: 1+

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Death Penalty as a Deterrent - Opposing Viewpoints

One of the most controversial issues in today's America has to do with the question as to whether or not the death penalty is a deterrent to crime. Many of those that support the death penalty argue that execution, whether by lethal injection, the electric chair or hanging, is the most suitable penalty for persons who have committed atrocious crimes like first-degree murder, rape or the murder of a child. The main contention for these supporters is that the convicted person deserves punishment that is comparable to the crime; in addition, supporters of the death penalty argue that such an action demonstrates society's adherence to moral principles. According to Robert Bidinotto, such crimes as premeditated murder "is a crime in a class by itself," for it "negates the highest moral end of a civil society," being human life (156).

In contrast, those that are against the death penalty argue that even when a person commits murder, such an act does not justify death. This argument is supported by several examples -- first, the mental anguish that a condemned person experiences is a form of torture which has been denounced by many nations. Also, when a state or the federal government executes a person, it undermines its moral authority and subtracts from the value of human life.

The supporters of the death penalty have traditionally applied several reasons why civilized society is justified in putting to death those that commit horrendous crimes. One reason is retribution which allegedly satisfies the demands of society for punishing the criminal in accordance with the severity of his/her crime. With deterrence, those that support the death penalty point out that such an action deters would-be criminals from committing various crimes, especially murder. However, in the case of retribution, human beings naturally tend to want some kind of revenge against those that commit horrible crimes; thus, the supporters of the death penalty consider retribution as a viable reason to put someone to death.

In the case of deterrence, the death of a criminal who has committed murder obviously ends the criminal's opportunities to commit another murder. Conversely, as maintained by John O'Hair, a district attorney in the city of Detroit, "I do not think the death penalty is a deterrent of any consequence in preventing murders, (for) most homicides... are impulsive actions (and) crimes of passion in which the killers do not consider the consequences of what they are doing" (Espejo 18), meaning that before a murder is committed, the perpetrator does not normally consider the possibility that he/she could face the death penalty as a result of their actions.

The overall popularity of the death penalty in the United States is generally due to frustrations over violent crime and the attitude that capital punishment is needed in order to discourage people from committing murder or other violent crimes. But as shown in a survey conducted in 1995 by Richard Dieter, less than one percent out of 350 police chiefs and sheriffs from across the U.S. when asked if the death penalty was an effective deterrent to violent crime responded that it was a good way to reduce violent criminal activity (Pojman 256). However, as Hugo Bedau relates, when one examines the effects of the death penalty in those states that utilize it for punishment, "five states (show) the greatest relative improvements," namely, Georgia, South Carolina, Florida, Delaware and Texas, all of which "have aggressively (applied)...… READ MORE

How to Reference "Deterrent Effects of the Death Penalty" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

Death Penalty One of the Most Contentious Research Paper

Death Penalty

One of the most contentious issues in contemporary America is the continued use of the death penalty against certain offenders. For supporters, the death penalty is valuable because… read more

Research Paper 8 pages (2882 words) Sources: 5 Topic: Crime / Police / Criminal Justice

---

Capital Punishment the Death Penalty Term Paper

Capital Punishment

The death penalty is an unsatisfactory approach to serious crimes. Trends and the tide of public opinion through the years indicate this. According to Gregg Easterbrook (2000), the… read more

Term Paper 8 pages (2658 words) Sources: 5 Style: MLA Topic: Crime / Police / Criminal Justice

---

Why We Need Capital Punishment Term Paper

Capital Punishment (also called Death Penalty) is a highly contentious issue with both the advocates and opponents advancing numerous ethical, moral, and economic arguments for and against the continuance of… read more

Term Paper 5 pages (1839 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Crime / Police / Criminal Justice

---

Death Penalty as Long Term Paper

Death Penalty

As long as there has been a codified system of law, there has been a death penalty. In Hammurabi's Code, the first known set of codified laws, death… read more

Term Paper 8 pages (2930 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Crime / Police / Criminal Justice

---

Death Penalty Can it Ever Be Justified Term Paper

Death penalty cannot be equalled to murder or considered unjust. As an effective method of instilling the fear of committing crimes, capital punishment may be awarded against the worst and… read more

Term Paper 5 pages (1491 words) Sources: 5 Style: MLA Topic: Crime / Police / Criminal Justice

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>