Essay on "Designing Electoral Institutions"
Essay 4 pages (1232 words) Sources: 8
[EXCERPT] . . . .
dealt with the same topic of electoral law in different ways. Bawn's (1993) essay dealt with German electoral law as a social choice outcome. Her hypothesis was that individuals choose electoral institutions that maximize their future policy influence.The independent variable is the policy preference. The dependent variable is the electoral institution that results.
Bawn's (1993) conceptualizes the electoral system as one that is at least tri-fold consisting of:
a definition of what constitutes a vote…, a rule for how votes are totaled…, and a rule for translating vote share into seat allocations. (966)
As illustration of her argument that the selected electorate coincides with wishes of the party members, Bawn (1993) provides the instance of the Social Democratic Party (SPD) in the 1949 Parliamentary system in Germany. The SPD was the small party coalition and nonetheless was chosen as natural majority for choice of electoral system since it coincided with the choice of the small parties. Using mathematical calculations, some of them too abstruse for me, Bawn (1993) demonstrates that via corollaries, the SPD became the electorate as choice
Just as policy is matter of social choice, political institutions are too. Electoral institutions / systems are selected by the interests of the participants and by the institutions that make that choice therefore different electoral systems appear more prominent, or gain the spotlight in diffident eras.
Bawn's (1993) argument makes sense to me, particularly since it exemplifies Peter Bergman's thesis in sociology of knowledge about how
download full paper ⤓
The weakness in Bawn's (1993) argument is that social choice may not be the determinant argument in selection of the particular electorate. One or more reasons, extraneous to or supplementary to social choice can result in a selection of electorate subsystem. Social choice too, as in this context, can be interpreted as social duress where the party may feel compelled - but reluctant -- to choose the electorate as their representative party. The question then become one of whether this is choice or duress.
Gunther's (2003) hypothesis is that the perceptions, strategies, calculations, and behavior of party elicits may strongly determine electoral law and the overall shape of the party system. He bases this on survey and in-depth elite interview data from Spain in the 1970s and 1980s.
The IV here is the behavior and perception of the party elites. The DV consists of the direction and character of the Electoral system. Its shape hinges on characteristics of the elite.
Gunther (2003) conceptualizes the elite as party leaders. Those are the very tops that are heading the electorate system.
It is the elite that determine the distal effects of electoral laws and their consequent impact on the system's political direction.
The strengths of Gunther's study lie in the fact that close reasoning as well as data and statistical configurations have been used.… READ MORE
Quoted Instructions for "Designing Electoral Institutions" Assignment:
This is a critical essay. You must read the sources I will send and then do the next
briefly identify the central research questions
describe the dependent variable and the central independent variables addressing both the theoretical concepts and the ways the concepts are operationalized
lay out chief hypotheses, identify the causal mechanisms posited as linking the independent and dependent variables
appraise the strengths and weaknesses of the readings assigned, both in theoretical and empirical terms. This discussion would address:
the clarity and persuasiveness of the logic
the research design and methods used to evaluate the logic
the extent to which the evidence present supports the argument
draw conclusions. *****
How to Reference "Designing Electoral Institutions" Essay in a Bibliography
“Designing Electoral Institutions.” A1-TermPaper.com, 2011, https://www.a1-termpaper.com/topics/essay/dealt-same-topic/378378. Accessed 5 Oct 2024.
Related Essays:
Rights of Women in Islam Research Proposal
Misunderstood Role of Women in Islam
The Islamic faith represents one of the most widely spread and acknowledged religions in the world. Often misunderstood and even more often exploited, members… read more
Research Proposal 20 pages (6335 words) Sources: 3 Style: Harvard Topic: Religion / God / Theology
Reagan and the 80s Movie Term Paper
REAGAN & the 80S MOVIES
The objective of this work is to take a closer look into popular movies in the 1980s and the role Ronald Reagan's presidency played in… read more
Term Paper 17 pages (4752 words) Sources: 10 Topic: American History / United States
Sat, Oct 5, 2024
If you don't see the paper you need, we will write it for you!
We can write a new, 100% unique paper!