Essay on "Countermeasures Under the Law of State Responsibility"

Essay 8 pages (2852 words) Sources: 20

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Countermeasures Under the Law of State Responsibility

Who is entitled to adopt countermeasures under the law of state responsibility? Discuss with reference to recent state practice.

Throughout history, the responsibility of the state over its citizens and foreign nationals has been continually brought to the forefront. Part of the reason for this, is because the treatment of the minority population in a country was often ignored by the government. At which point, a variety of atrocities occurred, sparking enough outrage that various treaties and international accords were enacted to hold nation states accountable. A good example of this can be seen with the development of the International Red Cross in 1863. As five different individuals would form the organization to: address the public health and humanitarian issues that were often ignored by most governments. (Porter 1994, pp 1 -- 18) Over the course of time, this focus continued to grow and evolve to the point, that many government officials became concerned about the effects of the nation state on the lives of the individual. After World Wars I and II, it became obvious that nation states would engage in activities that were in the benefit of their own self-interest (regardless of the impact upon the civilian population). At which point, a series of different international organizations would be created to address these issues. This established, standards that would hold the nation state responsible for the way they treated the civilian population (in particular minorities and foreign nationals). As a result, the law of state responsibility would emerge as major tool that international organizations could use, to hold the different leaders of nation states accountable for such actions. Simply put, this is when the international community is creating various standards through agreements and treaties. As these obligations will hold the government and bureaucrats responsible for the actions as well as policies they implement against a group of people. (Porter 1994, pp 1 -- 18) This is significant, because the establishment of these standards has created a new level of accountability. Where, various governments realized that they must take into account the views of the different population groups within their borders. However, when these laws are violated some kind of countermeasures must be enacted to prevent these abuses from occurring. To determine who is required to enforce the different countermeasures requires: examining the rules surrounding laws of the state (through various treaties / agreements), what kind actions can be taken for any violations and who is responsible for enforcing them. Together, these different elements will provide the greatest insights as to who is responsible for adopting these countermeasures and how recent events are causing them to evolve.

The Laws of the State

After World War I, the laws of the state would slowly begin to emerge, as the different nations states felt that some kind of standards must be in place, to prevent the abuses that lead to the conflict. What happened was the industrial revolution and new technological innovations would mean that governments were exploiting minorities and other ethnic groups (in more perverse ways). As vast inequalities, would appear in societies and among the different nations around the world. This created the social conditions for the war to take place and it allowed for abuses to occur. At which point, a foundation was established for applying the laws of the state and different governments. After the end of World War II, these regulations would be expanded upon, to address the actions of the nation state towards the civilian population. The most notable include: the Declaration of the Rights of the Child (in 1923), the Universal Declaration on Human Rights (in 1948), the Vienna Declaration & Program Actions (in 1993), the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous People (in 2007) and the UN Declaration on Sexual Orientation & Gender Identity (in 2008).

The Declaration of the Rights of the Child would be the first kind of standards that were in place. It was designed to protect children against: exploitation, hunger, disease and a lack of support. As the law would require nation state to focus on helping to safeguard children and ensure that they have the ability to support themselves in the future. This is important, because this law would serve as the basic foundation for future regulations that were in place (regarding how children should be treated). (Convention of the Rights of the Child 2010)

The Universal Declaration on Human Rights was established in the aftermath of World War II. As nearly 375 nations were addressing the obvious abuses that occurred against the civilian population. At the heart of the agreement, are thirty different articles that define the role of the government in relation to the civilian population. Where, they are expected to follow a number of different standards ranging from: the right to life, liberty and security to the right to own property / work. This is significant, because the creation of these standards would clearly define the most appropriate way that nation states, should be interacting with their citizens and foreign nationals. (UN Declaration of Human Rights 2010)

The Vienna Declaration & Program Actions focused on improving the protection of human rights. As the end of the Cold War, would introduce a new focus on the international community, by preventing the obvious abuses that were occurring (despite various laws and standards that were in place). Under this agreement, human rights would be subdivided into different areas to include: political, social, economic, civil and cultural rights. This is important, because this law would focus on different aspects of how various minorities and other ethnic groups are discriminated against (by their respective nation states). As this agreement sought to address every form of injustices that could be occurring, by defining the numerous ways that this takes place. (Vienna Declaration and the Program of Action 2010)

The Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous People is not enforceable under international law. Instead, it is a suggestion as to how nation states should seek to address the issues of marginalization and discrimination of the native population. As these groups are often subject to most extreme amounts of negative reactions from the government. This is important, because it shows how the international community, is pushing nation states, to embrace the increased standards for the laws of responsibility. (Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous People 2007)

The UN Declaration on Sexual Orientation & Gender Identity is an open proposition that has not been fully ratified by the UN. This is focused on addressing various issues that could affect how women are treated by numerous governments and in society. Where, it is seeking to prevent various abuses from occurring against girls as well as women to include: discrimination, violence, harassment, stigmatization and exclusion. This is important, because it shows how the laws of state responsibility are continuing to increase. Even though this proposal has not been ratified, it is a symbol of the continuous focus on increasing the overall amounts of accountability (in the international community) over various nation states. (Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity 2008)

When you step back and analyze the different laws of the state, it is clear that they are continuing to evolve. Part of the reason for this, is because the current standards could be ignoring certain aspects of human rights. At which point, various proposals will be introduced that are non-binding, but highlight the obvious abuses that are occurring. Over the course of time, these different standards will become more universally accepted. At which point, they will become a part of law of state responsibility. As the acceptance of them, by the majority of the international community, will mean that they are enforceable under international law. A good example of this can be seen with the Rome Statue of 1998. As this would establish the International Criminal Court (ICC) and it would make genocide as well as crimes against humanity punishable for all nations (under international law). (Boot 2002, pp 1- 19) This is significant, because the standards that were implemented after World War II have evolved to the point that they apply to all governments. As the changing focus, is holding bureaucrats and nation states accountable for how they are treating the civilian population.

What Actions can be taken for Violations / who is Responsible for enforcing them?

When there are any significant violations of the state of responsibility, the matter will be reported to UN Security Council from a UN watchdog organization (such as: the UN Human Rights Commission). The idea is that the Security Council is responsible for promoting peace and stability. As a result, any kind of violations that are reported will see various resolutions passed, calling for a particular nation state to follow different international standards and agreements. Yet, when a nation state continues to refuse to follow these different standards, the Security Council will take action condemning as well as authorizing the use of various corrective countermeasures. To include: coordination / diplomacy, through utilizing established… READ MORE

How to Reference "Countermeasures Under the Law of State Responsibility" Essay in a Bibliography

Related Essays:

Cyber-Citizen, USA Cyber-Citizen USA the Debate Research Paper

Cyber-Citizen, USA

Cyber-citizen USA

The debate over systems security

"If you see something, say something," the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) promotes the use of internet communications to warn… read more

Research Paper 20 pages (5130 words) Sources: 12 Topic: Terrorism / Extremism / Radicalization

---

Transportation Security in the United States Research Proposal

Transportation - Security

CONTEMPORARY TRANSPORTATION SECURITY ISSUES in the U.S.

The Historical Evolution of Contemporary Transportation Security Issues

Airline Hijacking and Attacks on Transportation as Political Terrorism:

The first hijacking… read more

Research Proposal 25 pages (6826 words) Sources: 10 Style: APA Topic: Transportation / Mass Transit

---

Business Law - Bug, Inc. Case Term Paper

Business Law - BUG, Inc.

Case: BUG, Inc., a company based in Any State, U.S.A., designs, manufactures, and sells electronic recording devices. These devices are used by law enforcement agencies… read more

Term Paper 5 pages (1972 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Business / Corporations / E-commerce

---

Comprehensive Study of Offshore Financial Centers and Their Effects on Global Economy Dissertation

Offshore Financial Centres and Their Effects on Global Economy

The past 3 decades or so have witnessed the proliferation of offshore financial centres that have drawn both criticism and praise… read more

Dissertation 60 pages (22477 words) Sources: 20 Topic: Economics / Finance / Banking

---

Admin Law Term Paper

Vaccines

The issue at hand is why federal agencies will not take liability for the use of the Swine Flu Vaccine or the Anthrax Vaccine, both of which are clearly… read more

Term Paper 5 pages (1598 words) Sources: 5 Topic: Medicine / Pharmacy

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>