Term Paper on "Competitive Advantage Mnes New Organizational Strategies"

Term Paper 11 pages (2922 words) Sources: 1+

[EXCERPT] . . . .

competitive advantage MNEs

NEW ORGANIZATIONAL STRATEGIES and STRUCTURES for COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE in the GLOBAL Business ENVIRONMENT

The objective of this work is to "assume the position of a member of the strategic planning team in a large multinational enterprise (MNE). It has been acknowledged by the team that other MNEs appear to have set out changing the strategies and structures of the organizations in order to obtain competitive advantage in the changing global environment. A written report is required that: (1) examines the major determinants of the control strategies adopted by MNEs and the extent to which they parent companies are prepared to allow their subsidiaries decision making autonomy; and (2) describe the organizational structures used to implement such strategies, the types of control mechanisms most likely to be used and explain why these might be deemed effective gi9ven the control strategy(s) adopted. Finally this report will research and examine the theoretical and empirical literature and illustrate the points with examples. Two MNE structures will be contrasted. This work has chosen Marks & Spencer and Johnson & Johnson for comparison.

Introduction

Today's business world is characterized by rapid changes. If the multinational enterprise must keep pace with these changes if they are to maintain a competitive advantage. There are five sets of environmental forces that must be taken into consideration by the MNE which are:

1) Industry Structure;

2) Macroeconomic variables;

3) Political variables;

4) Societal variables; and 5) Technological variables.

The industry structure is related to the "responses to strategies of customers, suppliers and competitors, dependence of profitability on unique value-added exchange rates, inflation rates, interest rates, and unemployment rates.

Macroeconomic variables are related to "Income levels and growth rates, foreign exchange rates, inflation rates, interest rates, and unemployment rates." (Conklin, 2003)

Political variables are the factors of "regulations, financial incentives, taxation, foreign investment restrictions and international trade and investment agreements." (Conklin, 2003)

Societal variables include: "Labor and environmental practices, ethics, corporate social responsibility, Boards of Directors, and demographics." (Conklin, 2003)

Technological variables include: "Technological infrastructure and the pace and direction of technological changes, including in particular the Internet and e-business." (Conklin, 2003)

Conceptual Frameworks

In making an examination of the conceptual frameworks used in the analysis of industry structure reveals several different existing frameworks. The first of these is a model referred to as Porter's Five Forces which makes analysis of an industry from the perspective of the existing competition, the threat of new entrants into the market, the buyer's bargaining power, the threat demonstrated by substitutes in the market and the supplier's bargaining power. There is a sixth force that can be added to this model which is that of the "impacts of complementors." (Conklin, 2003) the structure of the industry in one country may be quite different in another country and this "may provide a rationale for international investment" which has the capacity to empower a firm to realize increased profit through moving from one market to another to realize advantages due to unique activity provision.

Critical differences in the structure of the industry from county to country is due to environmental forces such as economic development levels, political regulations and consumer preference technological elements as well. The work entitled: "Designing a New Course: The Global Environment of Business" points out the discussion of Douglas North who holds that the institutions within a country are able to actually shape the international competitiveness of an industry. It has been proposed by Brandenburger and Nalebuff that an analysis that can be effectively used for an industry is that as shown in the following diagram labeled Figure 1.

Brandenburger and Nalebuff state each corporation should utilize 'PARTS' as "a comprehensive, theory-based set of levers" that help generate strategies. PARTS is stated to represent the number of PLAYERS that might be changed upon entrance of a corporation into that industry. The ADDED VALUES may change through the added value of others being lowered while increasing one's own. RULES may be changed by the corporation due to development of new policies in pricing and the corporation may very well change TACTICS altering the view of others and the resulting decisions. The SCOPE of the game may change through breaking or cutting ties with former alliances and building new alliances. (Conklin, 2003; paraphrased)

The industry may be viewed as a "value chain" which holds analysis to be one of added value to the products of services through alternative business activities. In the evaluation of the international competitiveness Michael Porter has proposed a 'diamond framework'. Differential opportunities for investment differ between countries specifically as to "factor conditions, demand conditions, rivalry among competitors and related and supporting industries." (Ibid) When all of this is added to government's role in the industry there is a potential combination that creates the competitive advantage and the 'cluster' of firms is seen to develop. When conducting this type of analysis one must remember that the new factors in international trade and investment agreements have the potential to "radically alter" the diamond and change the competitive advantage of an industry or country competitiveness. Stated is that: "Trade and investment agreements, together with an industry structure of a value chain or a creative web can facilitate the location of separable activities in different countries, with each country offering a competitive advantage for a specific type of activity, leading to the concept of an activity/country competitive advantage." (Ibid)

The different government structures throughout the world help shape the political environment of businesses. These governments range from dictatorships to democratic elected officials to parliamentary systems. Just as each government structure is unique the role that the government plays in the lobbying process is that which differentiates the type of relations that exist between government and business. For instant what were generally viewed as 'domestic' policy has the world of free trade become restrictive barriers to trade and as well have restricted activities in foreign investment. Other factors that may restrict international trade in services are restrictions relating to immigration or travel. Intellectual property is of primary importance in today's high-tech business market with issues including dumping, competitive policy, environmental standards and labor standards all being factors necessary for consideration. Other factors include harmonization of taxes and technical standard differences. Societal forces include differences in culture, values and ethics which differ a great deal from one industry to another. Other factors of possible import are inclusive of differing societal forces. Technological gaps that exist throughout the world greatly impact the ability of a firm such as the impact when infrastructure deficiencies exist specifically in the recent past in the case of e-commerce. Inclusive are agreement such as the 'Kyoto Protocol' with its' focus on technological changes in the reduction of pollution.

II. Technology Identified as Critical Element in Emerging New Organizational Forms

The work of Zornoza and Alcami entitled: "The Enabling Role of Information Technologies on the Emergence of New Organizational Forms" states that if an organization is going to manage survival in a competitive environment characterized by "turbulence that is engulfing a growing number of industries, firms will need to pinpoint innovative practices rapidly, to communicate them to their suppliers and to stimulate further innovation." In fact according to Zornoza and Alcami the following authors are convinced "that the networks are the organizational structures of the future":

Thorelli (1986)

Miles, 1989;

Szarka (1990)

Larson (1991)

Easton (1992)

Hinterhuber and Levin (1994)

The 'network' theory is one that examines deeply the types of relationships that exist among enterprises. " (Ibid) the network as defined by Knoke and Kuklinski (1983) is "a specific kind of relationship joining a particular group of people, objects or events. The work of Johan Lembke entitled: "Global Competition and Strategies in the Information and Communications Technology Industry: A Liberal Strategic Approach" (2002) conducts an examination of the roles that multinational corporations and the European Union play in the structuring of competition globally around wireless standardization. Analyzed are the "realities of global competition in formation and communications technology (ICT) markets from a more liberal-strategic viewpoint than the subsidy-based industry supported." This work holds that the approach take by the EU and the Multinational corporations is one that is an "aggressive outward-oriented strategy."(2004)

III. Marks & Spencer

The competitive advantage of Marks & Spencer rest squarely on: "the structure of its relationships with suppliers and employers, and on its brand and reputation. Marks & Spencer demonstrated the importance of key internal and external relationships to competitive advantage through its productive relationships that were long-term relationship with both its workforce and its suppliers. Another area that Marks and Spencer creates a competitive advantage in is their purchasing methods. Marks and Spencer do not "buy its products 'off-the-shelf' from suppliers. Instead technologists, designers, buyers and merchandisers from both sides- along with the raw material producers - work together to identify new products and designs." (Buyer Behavior and Relationship Development, 2001) in fact the customer is viewed by most manufacturers as being the customer of the retail company only however, integration at all levels… READ MORE

How to Reference "Competitive Advantage Mnes New Organizational Strategies" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

People Management to Strategic Human Resource Essay

People Management to Strategic Human Resource Management

The future of multinational corporations in global competitive market forces depends on the ability of global companies "to change and adapt their resources… read more

Essay 10 pages (3191 words) Sources: 10 Style: Harvard Topic: Management / Organizations

---

Cultural Diversity in Organizations Organization Behavior Today Thesis

Cultural Diversity in Organizations

Organization Behavior

Today, globalization is a widely spread phenomenon making boundaries between countries fade away. It has a great impact on organizations and consumers because it… read more

Thesis 17 pages (4681 words) Sources: 10 Topic: Anthropology / Culture

---

Business Enterprise and Innovation Essay

Business Enterprise and Innovation in China

The 21st century has been called "The Century of Asia" with China clearly leading the pack. One of the driving forces behind China's economic… read more

Essay 10 pages (2699 words) Sources: 10 Style: Harvard Topic: Engineering / Mechanics

---

Porter's Five Forces of Competition Research Paper

Porter's Five Forces Of Competition

Imagine studying the biggest social network website in the world. As everyone knows this is Facebook. They are a giant when it comes to bringing… read more

Research Paper 10 pages (3588 words) Sources: 10 Style: APA Topic: Computers / IT / Internet

---

Honda Is Significantly Smaller Term Paper

Honda is significantly smaller

Honda - to consider M&a and JV or continue on its own?

The economic literature provides arguments for parnerships/take-overs and continuing on its own depending from… read more

Term Paper 7 pages (2153 words) Sources: 1+ Style: MLA Topic: Business / Corporations / E-commerce

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>