Essay on "Comparing and Contrasting Clinical Supervision and Peer Coaching"

Essay 4 pages (1337 words) Sources: 4

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Clinical Supervision and Peer Coaching

Peer coaching for principals and clinical supervision are the two strategies to be compared and contrasted in this paper.

Peer Coaching

Peer coaching is a professional development model in which a formal, collegial process takes place; in this model pairs of faculty members volunteer to team up together to "…improve or expand their approaches to teaching,": according to a peer-reviewed article in the journal Innovations in Higher Education (Huston, et al., 2007). One interesting aspect of peer coaching is that each partner in the pair may actually serve "…as coach to the other," Huston explains. And yet it can also be just one way, with one of the partners playing the role of coach and the other the learner, or recipient of the coaching experience (Huston, 6).

Peer coaching, also known as "peer mentoring," offers several potential benefits, Huston continues on page 6. Those benefits include: a) improved morale and motivation for the faculty (or in this case, for the principal and other administrators in addition to the faculty); b) "increased collaboration" with members of the school administration; and c) more "thoughtful attention" to one's leadership position in a school environment (Huston, 6). And while this article zeros in on faculty peer coaching, the principles set forth relate seamlessly to the administration side of the school, the principals in particular.

It is important to remember that peer coaching -- when it is reciprocal and grounded in "mutual respect and trust" -- can "virtually guarantee the positive approach essential for constructive change" in a school environment (Huston, 7).

There are three steps that generally take place in a peer coaching situation, Huston explains. Those steps include: a) consultation in order to identify the "focus of the coaching"; b) open-minded observation by the coach; and c) a session where the coach is debriefed and relates to his or her observations of what took place (8).

The strengths and weaknesses of peer coaching

The strengths of peer coaching are many; for one, it allows critical reflection on the many duties and responsibilities that a principal faces every day. Also, since society changes and students change, and because of these dynamics educators must never stop learning, it provides the chance for "rich learning" in that coaching and being coached stimulates the thought process (Huston, 12). The authors point out that iconic educator and psychologist John Dewey believed "…authentic learning could only come from the investigation of solving real problems and reflecting on the experience of doing so" (Huston, 12). Peer coaching is a way of investigating the here and now of real problems, and it opens the door for sorting them out through interaction with respected colleagues.

An article in Educational Leadership recounted a peer coaching experience in Pennsylvania in which the relative isolation of the school was contributing to the "…perpetuation of poor supervisory techniques" (Gibble, et al., 1987). The model carefully laid out ways to assess the skills of the teachers and of the principals at a high school, and to plan for how those skills would be evaluated.

The principals who engaged in the peer coaching process in Pennsylvania had two goals. One, two principals would observe a teacher together, and later compare and contrast their notes about the quality of that teacher's work. The interaction between two principals was intended to actually help them do their jobs more effectively. The second goal would have two principals meet with the teacher afterwards in a post-conference meeting. Working together for the principals served to be an "excellent tool for improving our supervisory conferences with our teachers" (Gibble, 73).

The only way there could be weaknesses in the peer coaching of principals is if the program was not well thought out; or if the two principals paired up to be coached did not fully and honestly interact with each other. Principals are busy professionals with a list of issues to face every day; but if they get too bogged down in the bureaucracy and have no… READ MORE

How to Reference "Comparing and Contrasting Clinical Supervision and Peer Coaching" Essay in a Bibliography

Related Essays:

Classroom Behavior Management Policies Research Paper

Classroom Behavior Management Policies

Title suggestions:

Bridging the Gap Between Systems Theory and Elementary Classroom Management

An Evolution: Systems Theory and Classroom Management

BREADTH

Systems Theory by the Three B's… read more

Research Paper 80 pages (23815 words) Sources: 31 Topic: Sociology / Society

---

Benefits of the Creative Process for Dementia Thesis

Framework and General Research Questions

The Kolb Experiential Learning Theory will represent the framework used for understanding the meaning dementia patients may be assigning to the art process. According to… read more

Thesis 35 pages (12767 words) Sources: 10 Style: APA Topic: Aging / Death / Gerontology

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>