Term Paper on "Frankenstein and Candide"

Term Paper 8 pages (2597 words) Sources: 1+

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Candide & Frankenstein

The Fall of Man, the Fall of Humanity from a State of Grace: The failure of religion and science in both Mary Shelley's Frankenstein and Voltaire's Candide

Both Mary Shelley's Frankenstein and Voltaire's Candide show the failure of ideology -- namely the inability of human beings to frame their lives according to a narrow doctrine, however superficially persuasive that doctrine might seem upon its surface. It does not matter if the doctrine is political, religious, or even scientific in nature -- the use of satirical or science fiction underlines the importance of idiosyncrasies in human narrative, nature, and thought. In the case of Voltaire's Candide, of course, the doctrine that is 'deflated' is that all human beings live in the best of all possible worlds. In the case of Mary Shelley's Frankenstein the ideology the text desires to deflate is more subtly expressed. Shelley seeks to deflate the religious definitions of limits of humanity and the Enlightenment scientific impulse's belief that all human needs are rational.

Why was this such a concern during the authorship of both texts that have such similar concerns yet such distinct styles? Religion and the role of the state were two of the most controversial public issues during the centuries when Shelley and Voltaire wrote, and both texts thus seem to feel duty-bound to grapple with these issue, one text through the fictional and character-driven vehicle of the novel, the other, earlier text through that of the picaresque, or travel nature of satire. By showing the failure of either Enlightenment or religious ideology distilled in their most general essences to satisfy the complex needs of human existence, both authors show the failure of doctrines, particularly in religious form in Candide, and particularly in rational form in Frankenstein, to satisfy human needs.

Voltaire begins his satire Candide in the house of the Baron Thunder-ten-tronckh, who "was one of the most powerful lords in Westphalia." Candide, the novel's titular hero and main protagonist, immediately strikes the reader as a kind of innocent, an untouched and untaught blank slate or tabula rasa example of humanity. Candide the character is utterly subject to the whims of his patron the baron and the tutor Pangloss, whom the baron has commissioned as his educator. The book suggests the ability first and foremost for education to shape the developing mind and character of a child from birth. Although this recalls Rousseau's ideal of education, it is important to note that although Candide is being educated in political and liberal philosophy in school, in reality the text is set not in a democracy, but in a dictatorship.

There Baron Thunder-ten-tronckh "was called 'My Lord' by all his people, and he never told a story but everyone laughed at it." In this beautiful but stifling aristocratic fiefdom, "Master Pangloss taught the metaphysico-theologo-cosmolonigology" to Candide, a "youth whom Nature had endowed with a most sweet disposition. His [Candide's] face was the true index of his mind. He had a solid judgment joined to the most unaffected simplicity; and [that is why] hence, I presume, he had his name of Candide," or candidness. The teachings of Pangloss make sense in this paradise, however, because of the utter domination of the baron's influence and the wealth enjoyed by all who fawn at his feet. Once death and destruction come to the community, the metaphysics advocated by Pangloss make little sense to anyone, including the reader as well as Westphalia's inhabitants. (Voltaire, Chapter 1)

Before Westphalia is invaded, Pangloss could easily prove "to admiration that there is no effect without a cause; and, that in this best of all possible worlds, the Baron's castle was the most magnificent of all castles," but as political events do not support the existence of this ideology, Pangloss' advanced ideology grows increasingly foolish to the eyes of the reader if not his determined pupils. Thus, still, in the face of all odds, Candide, his tutor, and the daughter of the Baron Thunder-ten-tronckh Miss Cunegund, stubbornly hold to the doctrine of the world's perfectibility, more out of determination to carry on a foolishly outmoded ideology that provides structure and solace, rather than a true search of truth. (Voltaire, Chapter 1)

Even from the beginning of the tale, the fissures of the state's goodness as well as Pangloss' ideology are questioned. After all, the old servants of the house of the Baron suspect that Candide, rather than being taken on because of baronial goodwill, was selected as he was the illegitimate son of the Baron's sister, "by a very good sort of a gentleman of the neighborhood, whom that young lady refused to marry." (Voltaire, Chapter 1) This infidelity on the part of the supposedly moral aristocracy seems not only hypocritical, but grows increasingly distasteful as it is even practiced by the supposedly more moral theological powers of the satire. Candide, in Chapter 9, dispatches both a Grand Inquisitor (after he has been reunited with Pangloss and faced the Inquisition) an ostensibly pious Jew, after they have been both enjoying the favors of Cunegund.

Later on, in increasingly irreverent and fantastical language, "The History of the Old Woman," detailed in Chapter 11, relates how the woman who helps Candide and Cunegund escape from the clutches of the Inquisition is also, like Candide, an illegitimate child -- but she is not the daughter of a baron, rather she is the bastard daughter of the supposedly celibate Pope Urban X, thus the Princess of Palestrina! In this part of the tale, test the debauchment of Cunegund sound too awful, by her faith-believing captors, remember that she willingly submitted to the advances of her tutor Pangloss, too, while she was his pupil.

Thus, Popes, Baron, as well as philosophy tutors are fundamentally sexually motivated beings whose behavior does not adhere to a rigidly fixed ideology, even if they may espouse such an ideology and consciously believe in their advocated doctrine, over the course of Candide. Even Pangloss seems to participate in this transparent hypocrisy in his behavior towards Cunegund. For Voltaire, in human practice, neither theology nor piety to the state serves to induce moral behavior upon the part of rulers or ruled. This suggests there is a strong defense of Enlightenment political freedom and rational destruction of old, institutionalized traditions of Kings and the Catholic Church in Candide.

But the rational defense of a particular ideology, whether of human or worldly goodness, is not possible either. The satirical nature of the travelogue that characterizes the novel, piling one absurdity upon the next absurd event, suggests that rationality is not a perfect mode to understand human life in its entirety, either. Pangloss is an absurd character, yet despite even his own blatant defiance of his belief system, as well as the ebb and flux of life to consistently turn good to bad, he seems to actually place credence in his notions of the world's intrinsic goodness.

Rather than fully validate pure rationality as a way of understanding an irrational world, the Voltaire satire ends more on a Romantic rather than realistic note, not a rationalistic note at all. At the novel's conclusion, the innate goodness of Candide the character has been strained to its breaking point by the horrific events the title character has suffered. The title character has suffered persecution, lost and won and lost fortunes of gold, and also lost his friends. The faithless Cunegund, whom he once desired to marry but could not because of his uncertain birth is subsequently, imposed upon him by her father the Baron. But once again life, and a woman's appearance, unlike ideology, is in constant flux and change. "Even the tender Candide, that affectionate lover, upon seeing his fair Cunegund all sunburned, with bleary eyes, a withered neck, wrinkled face and arms, all covered with a red scurf, started back with horror; but, not withstanding, recovering himself, he advanced towards her out of good manners. She embraced Candide and her brother; they embraced the old woman, and Candide ransomed them both." (Voltaire, Chapter 29)

Candide had, in truth, no great inclination to marry Miss Cunegund," given her infidelity and previous lack of reliability as well as her loss of beauty. (Voltaire, Chapter 30) but "the extreme impertinence of the Baron determined him to conclude the match; and Cunegund pressed him so warmly, that he could not recant." (Voltaire, Chapter 30)

Poor Candide -- this is even though the Baron's own impressments of his former ward are hypocritical, as he harbored Candide as an illegitimate child before, not as a prospective heir. And even at the end of the novel, the slightly more embittered Pangloss tries to stress to Candide, his former pupil, that "there is a concatenation of all events in the best of possible worlds; for, in short, had you not been kicked out of a fine castle for the love of Miss Cunegund; had you not been put into the Inquisition; had you not traveled over America on foot; had you not run… READ MORE

How to Reference "Frankenstein and Candide" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

Voltaire's Candide and Mary Shelley's Frankenstein Essay

Voltaire's Candide And Shelley's Frankenstein

One of my favorite sections in Voltaire's Candide involves Candide's interaction with Pangloss. We are told Pangloss is a philosophy teacher, but we soon learn… read more

Essay 4 pages (1179 words) Sources: 2 Style: MLA Topic: Literature / Poetry

---

Metaphysical Poetry Journal Exercise 3.1A: Addressing Love Journal

Metaphysical Poetry

Journal Exercise 3.1A: Addressing Love and Loss

I have left someone without knowing when I would see them again. It was a relationship that was very important to… read more

Journal 10 pages (3452 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Child Development / Youth / Teens

---

Beowulf as a Hero Lesson 1 Journal Journal

Beowulf as a Hero

Lesson 1 Journal Entry #

Journal Exercise 1.3A: What makes a hero?

Beowulf is a hero who possesses strength, courage and loyalty; these are the elements… read more

Journal 19 pages (8817 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Literature / Poetry

---

Henrik Ibsen's "A Doll's House (1879) Term Paper

Henrik Ibsen's "A Doll's House (1879)" became the landmark of realism, the prevalent genre of the theater during Ibsen's time. Realism was and is the literary movement that strives to… read more

Term Paper 6 pages (1875 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Family / Dating / Marriage

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>