Term Paper on "Canadian Human Rights and Civil Liberties"

Term Paper 4 pages (1385 words) Sources: 0 Style: APA

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Canadian Human Rights and Civil Liberties

The concepts of "procedural due process of law" and "substantive due process of law" have become a controversy in regard to the interpretation and application of the principle of fundamental justice as stated in Section 7 of the Canadian Human Rights and Civil Liberties. Why is this so? The primary purpose of the creation of Sections 7 to 14 is to protect the people of Canada in their dealings with the legal proceedings, particularly those who are being criminally charged. The Charter clearly guarantees the life, liberty, and personal security of all Canadians. Once the accused person is convicted, his or her liberty will be definitely lost.

In respect to the judicial process, the government ensures that fairness and justice are being observed in the whole process. Here, the fundamental right of an individual is guaranteed to be protected. This is where the due process of law is at work. The government will respect all of the person's legal rights, not just some or most of his or her rights. Historians and law practitioners have long debated the argument as to the fairness of the judicial procedure. To answer this concern, any accused is given the right to be heard and defend his side. This privilege is known as the procedural due process or a fair trial for the accused. However, the Canadian Charter of Rights does not contain any reference to "due process of law." This is substituted by the phrase "fundamental justice."

On the other hand, the substantive due process of law, as taken from the Lectric Law Library, is related with the "basis substance of the law to protect all individuals." This means that there is an equal protection for everyone. The court has interpreted 'fundamental justice' as the substantive concept. Some limitations are placed on laws and legal proceedings in order to guarantee the fundamental fairness, justice and liberty. This is where the problem lies - the vagueness of the concept of fundamental justice.

Let us consider the Motor Vehicle Act, where absolute liability is combined with imprisonment. According to Justice Lamer, it is a violation of the fundamental justice. This is a clear indication that the fundamental justice is not just confined with procedural matters but is also found in the legal system. Although the Charter apparently affirmed to protect the life, liberty and security of a person as one, the courts did not state them as three different rights. They may reflect one right, but not all of the three aspects need to be dominated for a violation of right to take place. If anyone of the rights has been deprived, it must be in accordance with the fundamentals of justice. Otherwise, it is just a mere violation of a person's legal rights.

Along with the government's effort to protect the individual's life, liberty, and personal security is a number of legislative orders passed into law such as the Criminal Code stating the criminal process as well as the corresponding penalty for a particular felony. There is also the presence of regulating bodies like the Commission on Human Rights, the Canadian Bill of Rights, and other law governing bodies. Since the court did not plainly specify the real meaning of Section 7, the application of other laws, particularly the criminal law will be in contradiction with one or more of an individual's legal rights. How and when do we prove that a person's right to life, liberty and security is violated? Is Section 7 violated by the deliberate abuse of any one of its three elements? Or does violation of all of the three elements need to be established? As stated earlier, the Supreme Court has rarely justified it. In the application of fundamental justice, violation of any one of the elements in Section 7 may only be saved in cases caused by natural conditions as stated in Section 1.

Among the conflicts involved regarding the fundamental justice are its sources. Is it based on the traditional justice system or is it patterned from international justice? For the society, the shared assumptions based on the cases and traditions that have… READ MORE

How to Reference "Canadian Human Rights and Civil Liberties" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

AIDS and Human Rights What Is the Best Approach Research Paper

human rights approach to HIV / AIDS

Human rights approach to HIV

AIDS, a health problem that was first clinically identified more than thirty years ago has grown to become… read more

Research Paper 5 pages (1702 words) Sources: 5 Topic: Disease / Virus / Disorder / Injury

---

Do Human Rights Following a Cultural Relativism Approach Depend on International Regimes for Their Implementation? Term Paper

Enforcement of Non-Universal Human Rights

There are some practices that are so abhorrent and degrading that they simply cannot be justified -- ever.

Genocide will never be successfully defended with… read more

Term Paper 30 pages (7536 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Anthropology / Culture

---

Loss of Civil Liberties Due to International Terrorism Research Proposal

Terrorism and Loss of Civil Liberties

Terrorism and Civil Liberties

The aftermath of September 11 has been a controversial and challenging period for the U.S. Ethnic profiling and speculation without… read more

Research Proposal 7 pages (1769 words) Sources: 7 Style: APA Topic: Terrorism / Extremism / Radicalization

---

Human Security Term Paper

Human security is a rising example for grasping the global susceptibilities whose advocates are challenging the tradition of ideas of national security by debating that the correct referent for security… read more

Term Paper 5 pages (1459 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: World History

---

What Is to Be Done? Term Paper

NThe Effectiveness of Human Rights

As humanity experienced progress, it became absolutely necessarily for society to function in agreement with certain basic laws in order to avoid that chaos. For… read more

Term Paper 5 pages (1570 words) Sources: 6 Topic: Terrorism / Extremism / Radicalization

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>