Term Paper on "Political Science Presidential Studies George W. Bush"

Term Paper 10 pages (3444 words) Sources: 1+

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Bush's Brain: How Karl Rove Made George W. Bush Presidential

Bush's Brain - How Karl Rove Made George W. Bush Presidential

This book was published in 2003, the handiwork of veteran political journalists James Moore and Wayne Slater. At the time of its arrival on bookshelves, Karl Rove was seen as an incredibly gifted and cunning presidential advisor and policy maker. He still is those things, but his star has fallen considerably. As the book went on sale, the 2004 Presidential Election was just ahead, and Rove's influence and reputation as a brilliant political tactician would grow even more. But following the Democratic takeover of the U.S. House of Representatives and the U.S. Senate in November, 2006, there is these days some tarnish on the luster Rove has built up as a strategist. In fact, it appears that Rove's strategy for the 2006 Mid-Term elections - to energize Bush's conservative demographics, to attack the Democrats (who opposed the war in Iraq) as friendly to the terrorists and to belittle them as "cut-and-run" cowards.

That strategy backfired, as apparently Rove (and Bush) forgot the concerns of the middle class, forgot how angry those in the middle of the political spectrum were about the disaster in Iraq, about high gas prices, about the daily revelations of corruption in Washington (much of it pointing at Republicans). But that having been said, Karl Rove will nonetheless go down in political history as the man behind whatever success George W. Bush is ultimately credited with.

Meanwhile, the opening page on James Moore and Wayne Slater's book, Bush's Brain - How Karl Rove Made George W. Bush Presidential, quotes Plato as saying: "One of the penalties for refusing to participate in politics is that you end up being governed by your inferiors." That is a very interesting choice of Platonic quotations, and even ironic. Its ironic for two reasons; one, there is a substantial body of opinion in the scholarly / progressive / academic communities that portrays Bush as intellectually inferior. When a person objectively analyzes the intellectual firepower of many presidents down the years, Bush's malapropos and fumbling / bumbling extemporaneous speaking leave the impression that he's not too terribly bright. As this book points out, Bush hasn't needed to be bright; he has had Rove to rely on.

A close examination of a question and answer Bush press conference by a media-wise individual will bring to light numerous misstatements and surprisingly shallow rhetoric. And two, the irony is there because the Bush family is seen as a rich clan from the east that became Texans for political reasons, and there is a perception, right or wrong, that they think they are better than others who don't swim in the same kind of financial glory.

There is a general perception in America that the Bush family is arrogant, and some of that comes from Bush's actions as a president (an extremely partisan politician notwithstanding the fact that he came into Washington saying he was "a uniter"; he also pushed his own personal covert anti-terrorist agenda in spite of federal law that requires certain steps prior to wiretapping innocent civilians), and some comes from his family. For example, his mother, Barbara Bush, was quoted making quite condescending remarks about the low-income folks who were refugees from the Hurricane Katrina and were brought to Houston when their homes were flooded.

And his brother, Neil gives off an arrogant vibe, as well; it was recently revealed that Neil bush is profiting from the legislation, No Child Left Behind, by selling an expensive interactive reading aid (video-powered) to a number of the schools that are receiving federal money from No Child Left Behind.

Review and Analysis of Moore and Slater's Book

Meanwhile, that having been presented purely as background into the bigger picture of the Bush presidential story, in this book Moore and Slater have done a very thorough job of showing readers Karl Rove's role in the George W. Bush success story. On page 7 the authors quote University of Texas presidential scholar Bruce Buchanan; "He wouldn't have had the vision on his own. He wouldn't have had the game plan. He wouldn't have had the agenda." These are all true statements, which makes an even more remarkable story when Rove's genius is factored in.

What has Rove got that powers him to work so hard, and strategize so effectively, that he can take a rather ordinary politician like Bush and send him to the White House. This book is packed with explanations and antidotal evidence of what Rove has not only meant to Bush, but to the Republican Party and ultimately to the United States.

The guy's got an extra chromosome," says Bush media advisor Mark McKinnon (p. 8), speaking of Rove's acumen. The authors lay mountains of praise on Rove throughout the first ten or so pages, until they finally begin to dig down a little deeper into what a manipulating, dirty-tricks-playing scoundrel Rove has turned out to be. Indeed on page 11, "Bush is the product. Rove is the marketer," the authors explain, and those statements are true, but they don't go far enough. "Rove was the whetstone that sharpened bush into a presidential device," Moore and Slater explain. but, also on page 11, they begin to peel away the veneer and get down to the wood of the matter.

The inherent danger in an arrangement where the political advisor also drives policy," Moore and Slater write on page 11, "is that the consultant is deciding what is best for the next election cycle and his political party while the president needs to be considering what best serves the country beyond election day." Indeed, Rove's mastery over strategy and policy issues has actually been far and away the reason Bush is where he is. "Those two interests are frequently divergent and in conflict," Moore and Slater write. Rove has in fact brought a "rigorous intellect" and "superior political expertise" (and "capacity for detail") into the executive branch of government, and from all appearances, he's Bush's alter ego. The end result, whether his own party leaders - or the Democrats - like it or not, is "Karl Rove thinks it, and George W. Bush does it."

The bottom line? Rove is the "co-president of the United States." Is that a good thing? The rest of the book provides myriad and diverse answers to that question, and while only history will really be able to answer the question thoroughly, it is obviously a very dangerous dynamic to have one man, a man of questionable ethics, who was not elected by the voters, steering the country, pushing policy, manipulating issues in a way which allows his boss to get reelected, and to run roughshod over the Constitution and the Congress in order to consolidate power.

The candidate that Bush beat to repeat as Texas Governor in 1998, Garry Mauro, believes that Rove has "corrupted the democratic process" (p. 13). "Yeah, I think he's an evil man," Mauro is quoted as saying. Well, just how evil is Rove? Moore and Slater point to the wild flurry of vote counting in Florida in 2000, after the election that was to decide who would be president, Al Gore or George W. Bush. In the days immediately after the various recounts were launched, Moore and Slater point to documents release to the IRS 19 months after the election that show the Bush team had spent over a million dollars to "fly operatives into Florida and another million to pay their hotel bills" (p. 14). These "operatives" were hired to create "rowdy distractions at the recount headquarters," and the mastermind of dirty politics, Karl Rove, created all their mischief.

But the authors needed to go back much farther than that to show Rove's style of spreading rumors, initiating whisper campaigns, playing dirty tricks on opponents to make sure his candidate wins out. A newspaper article that appears on pages 25-27 of the book, reprinted from the Dallas Morning News reviewed some of the unethical Rove tactics. In 1973, Rove "organized conferences that instructed young Republicans on campaign dirty tricks, such as going through a rival's garbage to obtain inside memos and contributor lists."

In 1982, Moore and Slater continue, Rove was a consultant to Texas Governor Bill Clements, and Rove "distributed a mock newspaper suggesting that democratic challenger Mark White was drinking while driving when he had a wreck as a college student," according to the newspaper article written by Wayne Slater. White lost the campaign, having been smeared by Rove. In 1990, Rove was up to his old tricks, spreading information about an "alleged kickback scheme involving Democratic Agriculture commissioner Jim Hightower." Three of Hightower's aides were convicted on federal charges.

And in 1992, Rove passed along information that Lena Guerrero, State Railroad Commissioner and a "rising star in the Texas Democratic party," had "lied about graduating from college." After the story hit the front pages of Texas newspapers, Ms. Guerrero's political… READ MORE

How to Reference "Political Science Presidential Studies George W. Bush" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

George W. Bush Presidency Research Proposal

Bush Christian

The Bush Administration's Politicization of Christianity

State and Church are, by constitutional law, intended to remain separate. And yet, where America's electoral patterns are concerned, it is quite… read more

Research Proposal 13 pages (4214 words) Sources: 13 Style: MLA Topic: Genetics / DNA / Genes / Heredity

---

George W. Bush Research Proposal

Bush Religion

The Religious Policies of George W. Bush

The Bush Administration, which held the White House from 2000 to 2008, was an outright failure in most regards. During the… read more

Research Proposal 8 pages (2536 words) Sources: 8 Style: MLA Topic: American History / United States

---

Barack Obama in Political Time Term Paper

Barack Obama in Political Time

Renowned expert named Stephen Skowronek's visions have basically changed our accepting of the American position. His "political time" thesis has been chiefly powerful, enlightening how… read more

Term Paper 12 pages (3373 words) Sources: 8 Topic: American History / United States

---

Foreign Policy and Declining U.S. Influence Under the Bush and Obama Administrations Methodology Chapter

Consecutive Executive

George W. Obama & U.S. foreign policy doctrine

When the speech writer for the former U.S. secretary of state Condoleezza Rice, Christian Brose (2009) predicted that the continuum… read more

Methodology Chapter 12 pages (4436 words) Sources: 20 Topic: Government / Politics

---

Changes in Presidential Powers From Nixon to Bush Thesis

Presidential Studies

The transfer of power from one President to another is a crucial time in the life of a democratic nation. "Expansions of presidential power are not always the… read more

Thesis 8 pages (2836 words) Sources: 5 Style: APA Topic: American History / United States

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>