Essay on "Is Breaking the Law Acceptable Under Certain Circumstances?"

Essay 3 pages (1112 words) Sources: 3

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Breaking the Law

In his 1963 letter from a Birmingham jail, Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. expressed to his fellow clergymen his reasons for breaking the law. King declared that he could not "sit idly by" and watch injustice take place. He argued "Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere." Dr. King was willing to go to jail for his cause. He broke segregation laws to draw attention to the discrimination and hatred African-Americans were forced to endure throughout the United States but especially in the South. He was justified in breaking the law because the laws were man-made and perpetuated inhumanity and hate. Breaking the law is justified in such instances where laws are arbitrarily made and morally wrong.

More than fifty years after Dr. King penned the letter, it endures because of its eloquence and its message. Sharon Shahid argued recently in USA Today, only partly with tongue in cheek, that Dr. King's message might not have such a profound impact if written today, using today's technology. If Dr. King had "tweeted" from jail, his words would have reached a larger audience in much less time. Given the recent events in Egypt, where social media made an enormous difference in the outcome of the peaceful revolution, one might suppose that Dr. King could have likewise mobilized peaceful forces with 140-character bursts. Shahid calls King's voice "so poignant and crystal clear in print" and doubts that a text message could convey anywhere near the same urgency or convey the hardship, sacrifices, and pain. She further adds that, with Twitter, Dr. King's message would have been, minutes after it was released "drowned out by a thousand other disparate musings" (Shahid, 2011).

Unlike Malcolm X, who also fought for civil rights but sometimes frightened people with his fiery rhetoric, Dr. King never called whites names and never advocated hatred or violence. He denounced what he called the "black nationalist" movement, charging the movement was made up of people who had lost faith in America and "absolutely repudiated Christianity." Dr. King was a man of peace who believed that peaceful means could accomplish the mission. He believed violence would only beget further violence, leaving the streets of the South "flowing with blood."

Aeschliman (2005) argues that Dr. King's letter continues to stand the test of time and is comparable in importance to a number of great American documents. He calls the letter

"a document drawing on, appealing to, reaffirming, explaining, and extending the living tradition of the Declaration, the Constitution, the speeches and achievements of Lincoln,

the reforming zeal of Bryan and the two Roosevelts, and the commitments of American lives to two world wars. It also drew explicitly and eloquently on the Judaeo-Christian

tradition, containing a profound recognition of the religious source of ethics that had been central to most of the Founding Fathers (and especially to Washington, Adams,

Hamilton, Madison, and Jay), Lincoln, Bryan, and America's twentieth-century

Presidents."

Dr. King was jailed for parading without a permit. He called the law he violated "just on its face and unjust in its application." He pointed out there was nothing inherently wrong with an ordinance that requires a permit for a parade. The injustice was in the way the ordinance was applied. It was used to maintain segregation and to deny citizens the right they are guaranteed… READ MORE

How to Reference "Is Breaking the Law Acceptable Under Certain Circumstances?" Essay in a Bibliography

Related Essays:

Criminology: Definitional Sentences Technique of Neutralization Term Paper

Criminology: Definitional Sentences

Technique of neutralization: Neutralization theory proposes that although children may begin life with an innate moral obligation to obey legal authorities, when this sense of obligation is… read more

Term Paper 5 pages (2111 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Crime / Police / Criminal Justice

---

Criminal Justice Aggravated Assault, Which Is Occasionally Term Paper

Criminal Justice

Aggravated assault, which is occasionally known as felonious assault, is defined as the illegal intent or attempt to harm or cause serious bodily injury to another with or… read more

Term Paper 6 pages (2111 words) Sources: 1 Topic: Law / Legal / Jurisprudence

---

Analzying Christianity and the Torah Dissertation

This significance or relevance applies in new ways outside areas of theology and church such as in call for debt release for underdeveloped countries or as an ethic of nature… read more

Dissertation 150 pages (47287 words) Sources: 10 Style: MLA Topic:

---

Utopia, Thomas More Presents His Own Concept Term Paper

Utopia, Thomas More presents his own concept of what communal living should be in the most ideal setting in the 'ideal society.' More's communal aspects of his utopian plan include… read more

Term Paper 2 pages (587 words) Sources: 0 Topic: Sociology / Society

---

Ethics the Nursing Profession Term Paper

Ethics

The nursing profession, perhaps more than any other, is a veritable minefield of ethics issues and dilemmas. Because it is a caring profession, the focus of the nursing business… read more

Term Paper 9 pages (3034 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Ethics / Morality

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>