Essay on "Belize Telecom Case Comment: Implied Terms"

Essay 4 pages (1183 words) Sources: 2

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Belize Telecom

Case Comment: Implied Terms and Real Meanings

It is law's living nature that gives it such a compelling fascination; when the most minute of details can lead to the most profound changes in perspective and practical action, and when problems that would seem to be age-old lead to new conclusions and solutions, one cannot help but marvel at the purpose and the achievement of modern legal systems and judiciaries. Attorney General of Belize v Belize Telecom Ltd. [2009] UKPC 10; [2009] 2 All E.R. 1127 is a perfect case in point, with an obscure and highly unique contractual question resulting in a landmark ruling with significant implications in many areas of law. The ruling written by Lord Hoffmann in this case provides a means of establishing meaning out of ambiguities and gaps in a variety of legal documents, and in so doing both increases the practicality of these legal instruments and raises new questions about the care that must be taken in the composition of such documents.

Summary of Facts

The relatively straightforward question put before the Privy Council in this case stems from a rather strange provision and complex situation arising out of the privatization of Belize's telecommunications industry. Having taken control of the sole telecommunications provider in the country some years prior, Belize's government ultimately divested itself of all ownership shares in the company including a "special" share and all common C. shares it had maintained under the new company constitution. The holder of the special share is entitled, under this constitution, to appoint two of the eight directors on the board of the company, while shareholders of the C. stock were to elect four of these eight directors and the holders of the B. shares (private institutional investors) elected the final two directors. A provision in the constitution, however, provides that should the holder of the special share also hold 37.5% or more of the C. shares of the company, this shareholder would then appoint two additional directors, limiting the number of directors elected by other C. shareholders to two; these additional shareholders could only be removed through the action of the appointing entity. Belize Telecom became such a shareholder, appointed two directors to replace two of the C-elected directors (in addition to the two directors it appointed as the holder of the special share), then lost the majority of its C. shares back to the government via a debt default. Belize Telecom insisted that its appointed directors could not be removed, as there was no longer and entity holding both the special share (which Belize Telecom retained) and 37.5% of C. shares in the company, to which the government protested. The initial case judge sided with the Belize government, however two successive rounds of appeals fell in favor Belize Telecom and insisted that the company's constitution had not given a provision for the removal of directors in such a circumstance, and therefore that such a provision could not be assumed. Belize's attorney general appealed and advice was sought from the Privy Council.

Relevant Legal Issues

There are several highly significant and broadly influential legal issues at work in this case and in the decision Lord Hoffmann wrote, as well. The initial court that heard this case held that the company's constitution implied that directors appointed in the special circumstance were to vacate their seats in the event of a dissolution of the circumstance that enabled their appointment. At primary issue in the case before the Privy Council was whether or not this implication could be… READ MORE

How to Reference "Belize Telecom Case Comment: Implied Terms" Essay in a Bibliography

Related Essays:

Fact Pattern Case Study

Pattern

Case Study (Fact Pattern)

Criminal activities have been on the rise in many states of the United States. To control such criminals from going unpunished in the society, the… read more

Case Study 9 pages (2946 words) Sources: 9 Topic: Crime / Police / Criminal Justice

---

Telecom Act of 1996 Was Bad for Regional Bell Operating Companies Term Paper

Telecom Act of 1996 Was Bad for Regional Bell Operating Companies

On January 3rd, 1996, the Senate and the House of Representatives enacted the Telecommunications Act of 1996. The stated… read more

Term Paper 3 pages (785 words) Sources: 5 Style: MLA Topic: Computers / IT / Internet

---

Telecom Industry Term Paper

Telecom Industry

The total business of telecommunication in the current era is radically different from the past when corporations were allocated franchise territories decades ago. At that time customers were… read more

Term Paper 5 pages (2045 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Business / Corporations / E-commerce

---

Macular Hole Case Study

Because of her age and the fact that the hole was in its early stages, only monitoring was first prescribed. A cautious approach was determined given surgery contains some risks,… read more

Case Study 3 pages (1035 words) Sources: 3 Topic: Nursing / Doctor / Physician

---

From Harvard Business Review Silvio Case Study

Case Study from Harvard Business Review
Silvio Napoli and Schindler India (A)

Executive Summary
The case study chosen for this analysis is Silvio Napoli and Schindler
India (A) published by… read more

Case Study 3 pages (902 words) Sources: 2 Style: APA Topic: Business / Corporations / E-commerce

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>