Research Paper on "Balancing Ethical and Legal Considerations in Business"

Research Paper 8 pages (2693 words) Sources: 5

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Balancing Ethical and Legal Considerations in Business

Business ethics and the law have both stood out recently as two separate entities that help businesses operate under the specific cultural, moral, and financial framework. In fact, most businesses feature websites where they tout their commitment to normative ethical concepts while making sure that their customers understand that their patronage and appreciation is still key. This is a product of a renewed interest in business ethics and the legal landscape in the 1980's and 1990's, as much of academia became concerned with how businesses can operate both from a financially profitable aspect as well as a socially profitable one as well (Carasco and Singh, 2008). Emerging from this interest came the concept that businesses would be judged on not only their business performance, but also their efforts within the community and their promises to adhere to the legal framework of the country or countries they did business in. Ethics and the law can be viewed as two separate concepts for businesses, yet they both go hand in making sure that the business is viewed and judged in a way that casts it in a positive light. Another key understanding that many businesses have recently come to is the fact that, while it is not an outwardly attractive relationship, customers and profits come to those businesses that can convey themselves as community and environmentally conscious.

The idea that businesses have no other obligations other than making a profit was first made popular by economist Milton Friedman (Husted, 2008). This idea, while not entirely popular in the public realm, has been the backbone of business and commerce for hundreds of years. This is how many businesses still operate, but in a world where social connectivity has never been greater, and as businesses grow and emerge as key players within a globalized world economy, it is ever important to be perceived by peers and customers alike as being both profit and socially conscious. Certainly share and stakeholders have more basic, profit-motivated concerns than customers may, but all businesses must consider the benefits and costs of making sure they come out on top, ethically speaking. These motivations raise another question, about whether or not legal rule is morally acceptable (Anderson, 2008). Certainly the distinction between the law and morality exists, yet this distinction is far better defined in some places than in others, and remains as a separate consideration from profit-making.

Within their profit-making structure, businesses also have to adhere to the legal systems of the places they are operating. While this may seem a rather simple conclusion, it is important to recognize that not all countries' legal frameworks and sets of regulations are created equally in the eyes of business (Carasco and Singh, 2008). This is to say that for most businesses, there are both pros and cons to operating in certain places in the world. For example, a Canadian healthcare firm may have far more red tape to cut through relative to regulatory actions and regulations when coming out with a new drug treatment than say the same firm in a place like Russia (Svensson, Wood, Singh, and Callaghan, 2009). Both the ethical and legal considerations and frameworks are entirely different for the same business in the same industry in different countries. In this respect, the laws of business and the ethics of business are often formed at similar times in the business history of a nation or culture, and these considerations, while often synchronized on an individual basis, are not always so when compared to other nations and cultures around the world. In this way it is often morally or fiscally advantageous for certain businesses to be based or headquartered in one country and doing business or work in another (Carasco and Singh, 2008). Ethically, it may be shaky ground, but if this sort of behavior is healthy for the businesses' bottom line, it is often not a consideration, just as Freidman was eager to espouse.

The relationship between these two concepts, business law and business ethics, is therefore rather sticky, depending on the place of operation and the businesses' commitment to being socially and environmentally responsible (DuPlessis, Enman, Gunz, O'Byrne, 2011). This means that while the common ethics in a country are most often aligned with the laws, it may not always be the case that a business has to choose between "right" and "wrong" either ethically or legally. Certainly a business that is scrutinized publicly on a daily basis has to be much more careful to operate in a normatively ethical way, but this is not true for every business. When businesses decide to accept profits over ethics, it is often not a question of legality but a question of customer and outside perception. The ethical considerations are often outweighed by the potential for profits and pressure for creating an atmosphere of upward mobility both within and without a business (Svensson, Wood, Singh, and Callaghan, 2009). This can be seen at every level of management and employment at many firms, as people tend to become more ethically lax and cutthroat while moving up in the chain of command. Legally of course, there are no repercussions of stretching the truth or tattling on a co-worker to usurp a position or job title. While this behavior is frowned upon, there is little legislated to discourage it.

On the outside however, businesses are reluctant to be viewed as unethical, since this often cuts into the profit margin of a business in these environmentally-conscious times. Due to these concerns, most businesses have adopted internal corporate ethics policies, independent from the legal structure of their business (DuPlessis, Enman, Gunz, O'Byrne, 2011). This means that the corporate structure is not only governed by laws and regulations as well as normative ethical considerations, but a codified set of ethics that helps to regulate and govern the internal functions of the business and keep the outside image and internal moral of said business intact. This is an important part of most successful corporate structures and businesses and helps to encourage a positive working environment while, at the same time, leading the business to be viewed as more "friendly" and socially aware and conscious, which does help the businesses' bottom line, regardless of the internal cost of developing, implementing, and regulating such an ethics structure.

Business regulators are seldom concerned with ethics as much as they are with legal regulations and actions. This has always been so, and since there exists few agencies to regulate or even measure ethical considerations and actions in the business world, the law has remained as a lowest common denominator of sorts for businesses worldwide. Some people and businesses feel that more regulation and ethical framework is a positive thing for the economy and the business world since it forces businesses to be more transparent and honest in their disclosures (DuPlessis, Enman, Gunz, O'Byrne, 2011). Others, like Friedman himself, posit that from the realist and business-minded perspective, more regulation hinders economic development. But the questions surrounding ideas of over or under regulation and what amount of business law is best are often shrouded in political and business aspirations far removed from the floors of any corporation or structure. Certainly each country and specialized economy is different, and the vast complexity that is found in the world of ethics, regulation, and business is cause for closer, more specific examination of certain countries or ethical systems.

Business Law and Regulation: Helping or Hindering Canadian Businesses?

The questions of whether or not Canada has too much business law and whether it would be better off with less regulation are certainly controversial and their answers depend on the quantifying of many terms within the question. What does it mean for a country or a business to be "better off," and how much is "too much" regulation? These two questions are framed from the angle or assumption that there may indeed be too much law and regulation and that Canadian businesses and the economy itself may, in fact benefit from a less structured, less regulated legal system. These common assumptions must be more closely examined in order to unlock not only the meanings, but the social, ethical, and business implications of answering them. On certain stages, these questions are political and ethical powder kegs, touched off at the slightest mentioning of governmental restrictions, required transparency, and higher taxes. In Canada, these questions are far less provocative as they are within the U.S. legal structure, but they are equally as important in helping to decide and define the fate of the Canadian business world.

The implications for business and the regulatory structures within a country like Canada relative to the political leanings and beliefs found within the business world are profound (Husted, 2009). From the conservative perspective, businesses are hindered by more government, and the fewer regulations and governmental considerations a business has, the more latitude it is afforded to make a profit. This is assuming that profit and "what is… READ MORE

How to Reference "Balancing Ethical and Legal Considerations in Business" Research Paper in a Bibliography

Related Research Papers:

Legal Environment of Business Term Paper

Legal Business Environment

Legal Environment of Business

Modern businesses have to operate under a variety of laws and regulations. The business manger has to ensure that all federal and state… read more

Term Paper 10 pages (2863 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Law / Legal / Jurisprudence

---

Operations Management: Balancing Ethics With the Bottom Essay

Operations Management: Balancing Ethics With the Bottom Line

Description of the aspects of the case under investigation

Comparison and conclusion

Corporations are invariably mired in a state of tension between… read more

Essay 9 pages (2723 words) Sources: 1+ Style: Harvard Topic: Business / Corporations / E-commerce

---

Ethics of Headhunting Structure Business Ethics Corporate Term Paper

Ethics of Headhunting

Structure

Business Ethics

Corporate Social Responsibility

Social responsibility frameworks

Personal recruitment

External recruitment

Executive search

What are the choices facing organizations? What are the consequences?

Inductive and… read more

Term Paper 33 pages (9767 words) Sources: 50 Style: Harvard Topic: Business / Corporations / E-commerce

---

Company Structure a Pivotal Decision Term Paper

Company Structure

A pivotal decision that every person must undertake while starting a business venture is the legal structure to apply. It is this reason that the individual should seek… read more

Term Paper 7 pages (2068 words) Sources: 7 Topic: Business / Corporations / E-commerce

---

Corporate Philanthropy and the Development of Business Term Paper

Corporate Philanthropy on the Developjment of Business

The study conducted and reported in this work in writing is one that examines corporate philanthropy and that seeks to answer specific questions… read more

Term Paper 31 pages (8566 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Business / Corporations / E-commerce

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>