Essay on "Legal Case Autism ABA Ibi Treatments"

Essay 4 pages (1376 words) Sources: 2

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Auton v B.C.

Facts: Petitioner children with autism, through the ad litem, brought an action against the province of British Columbia, alleging that its failure to fund applied behavior therapy (ABA/IBI) for autism violated section 15(1) of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. While the government did fund programs for autistic children, financial constraints and the fact that the therapy was not universally acknowledged to be helpful prevented them from funding ABA/IBI therapy for all children with autism. The trial court found that the failure to fund ABA/IBI therapy violated the children's rights. The Court of Appeal upheld the trial court's decision. The government appealed the Court of Appeal's decision. The Court allowed the appeal and denied the cross-appeal.

Issues: Does the government's failure to provide ABA/IBI therapy for all children with autism violate the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms § 7 or 15(1)? When, if ever, is a province's public health plan under the Canada Health Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. C-6, required to provide treatment outside of those core services administered by doctors and hospitals?

Reasoning: The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms § 15(1) provides that "Every individual is equal before and under the law and has the right to the equal protection and equal benefit of the law without discrimination, and, in particular, without discrimination based on race, national or ethnic origin, colour, religion, sex, age or mental or physical disability" (Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms § 15(1)). A person claiming a violation of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms § 15(1) must establish four things: (1) differential treatment under the law, (2) on the basis of an enumerated or analogous ground; (3) which constitutes discrimination (Auton v. B.C. (2004), 3 S.C.R. 657).

Analysis: The Court determined that the government did not violate equality rights. The government is not required to provide funding for all medically required treatment. Instead, the law simply requires the government to provide funding for core services. ABA/IBI therapy for autistic children did not fall under the realm of core services. First, British Columbia had not designated providers of ABA/IBI therapy as health care practitioners whose services could be funded under the plan. Therefore, not only was B.C. not required to provide that funding, but its administrative body actually lacked the power to order such funding. In other words, the petitioners claim was not for a benefit provided for by law.

Furthermore, the legislative scheme was not discriminatory for failing to provide funding for ABA/IBI therapy to autistic children while providing funding for non-core services to members of other groups. The legislative scheme is a partial health plan, and it is not intended to meet all medical needs. The exclusion of non-core services is not enough to establish discrimination, since this failure is part of the legislative scheme. Moreover, there is no evidence that autistic children were targeted because of their disability. There was no example of a non-disabled group having access to the same type of emergent therapy that was being denied to the autistic children. "A legislative choice not to accord a particular benefit absent demonstration of discriminatory purpose, policy or effect does not offend this principle [of non-discrimination] and does not give rise to s. 15(1) review" (Auton v. B.C. (2004), 3 S.C.R. 657).

ABA/IBI therapy is the type of emerging therapy that should be considered a non-core service. It is an intensive therapy that has proven to have significant results in some cases, but is not considered successful in all cases. Furthermore, there are ethical concerns about how ABA/IBI therapy is performed, since its goal is to change how the child interacts with the world and its methods can be somewhat cruel.

Conclusion: The Court allowed the Province of British Columbia's appeal. The Court dismissed the cross-appeal by the petitioners. The Court determined that the definitions of benefits and health care practitioner found in the Medicare Protection Act, R.S.B.C. 1996, c.286 § 1 and the Medical and Health Care Services Regulation, B.C. Reg. 426/97 § 17-29 do not infringe the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms § 7 or 15(1) by failing to… READ MORE

How to Reference "Legal Case Autism ABA Ibi Treatments" Essay in a Bibliography

Related Essays:

Legal Case Analyses and Application Bilateral (Mutual) Essay

Legal Case Analyses and Application

Bilateral (Mutual) Mistake -- Inkel v. Pride Chevrolet-Pontiac Inc.

In this case, the buyer relied to his substantial detriment on a mistake in calculations made… read more

Essay 3 pages (1060 words) Sources: 3 Topic: Law / Legal / Jurisprudence

---

Ethical and Legal Perspectives in Health Care Case Study

Ybarra vs. Spangard Case Study

The issue of negligence is of paramount importance within a capitalistic societal structure, because as citizens engage in the open exchange of services, the party… read more

Case Study 4 pages (1405 words) Sources: 3 Topic: Law / Legal / Jurisprudence

---

Legal Environment and Impact on Organization Case Study

Legal Environment and Impact on Organization

The protection of personal information is of utmost importance in today's age of computers. So much private information about individuals is kept on computers,… read more

Case Study 3 pages (992 words) Sources: 3 Topic: Business / Corporations / E-commerce

---

Liability the Case With Virginia Pollard Case Study

Liability

The case with Virginia Pollard is showing how Teddy's Supplies is facing major legal challenges from the sexual harassment lawsuit. This is in spite of the New Jersey Supreme… read more

Case Study 3 pages (1331 words) Sources: 3 Topic: Law / Legal / Jurisprudence

---

Disparate Impact Disparate Treatment Case Study

Disparate Impact/Disparate Treatment case Study

Smith v. City of Jackson

The City of Jackson, Mississippi adopted a revised pay plan granting raises to all city employees in the Police and… read more

Case Study 3 pages (1297 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Law / Legal / Jurisprudence

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>