Term Paper on "Asylums in the 19th Century"

Term Paper 10 pages (3732 words) Sources: 10

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Asylums in the 19th Century

Asylums came into existence in response to a growing social problem -- what to do with people who were mentally ill. Of course, they were not called mentally ill in those days but were referred to as victims of lunacy or madness. The perception of madness as an illness came with the rise of psychiatry, and the development of psychiatry as a profession occurred concurrently with the development of asylums. This essay will consider conditions that led to the building of asylums, how asylums were meant to function, and the shift of function that occurred late in the 19th century.

Historians disagree about the efficacy of asylums for the treatment of those who were mentally ill, but all agree that conditions before asylums were for the most part degrading and inhumane to say the least. This was particularly true if the person was a pauper without funds to pay for care. In England, for example, the welfare administration -- the Poor Law -- cared for lunatic paupers. "Institutional care was provided and paid for from the public purse or was purchased by the parish at public expense from institutions run by private proprietors" (Murphy, 2001, p. 29). In London, mad houses were an industry that made lay proprietors rich and respectable. As Hughes (2002) points out, the idea of a "mixed economy" in which both state and private parties are involved in housing the mentally ill goes back to Victorian times. The two systems "public interest and private profit have operated in parallel..." (p. 328).

The Whitmore House, for instance, was owned and operated by Thomas Warburton who began at Whimore as an attendant. When the owner died, he married the owner's widow and thus acquired ownership. He habitually hired brutal, thuggish keepers and failed to supervise them.

A pamphlet written by a former "whistle-blowing" employee in 1816, "A Statement of the Curelties, Abuses, and Frauds which are Practised in Mad-Houses" resulted in a hearing. The pamphlet reported Warbuton took in as many people as he could get whether he had beds enough or not. Two or three people were often in the same bed. Crowding was only the beginning. "Brutal forced feeding, using objects such as a long spouted 'tea-pot' and a large key to crank open the mouth, resulted in smashed front teeth or even suffocation if the spout was pushed in too far and food passed down the windpipe. Mrs. Hodges, the wife of the vestry clerk for St. Andrew Holborn, had died of incompetent forced feeding... Pauper patients were left naked on wet straw beds in unheated rooms; soiled straw, filthy and infested with vermin, was unchanged for days. The limbs of the frail were 'mortified' by cold and neglect; one woman's foot had to be half amputated. Almost everyone was chained to the bedstead at night" (Murphy, 2001, p. 31). Inspectors, when they went to see for themselves, repeatedly gagged from the stench.

According to reports (Murphy, 2001), Warburton appeared to be puzzled when he was called before the Select Committee to explain the appalling conditions. He said the patients "could readily be controlled with a leg lock and manacles" (p. 32). He said the only restraint he used was "hobbles" and explained, "...almost in the manner you would put round a cow when milking..." (p. 32). Compounding the misery, patients had nothing to do and almost no medical treatment -- definitely nothing that could benefit a mentally ill person. In England, the Madhouse Act of 1828, provided for the First Middlesex County Asylum in Hanwell, West London to be built, but condition were poor there, too, and no treatment was offered (Psychiatric Hospital web site). After the 1845 Lunatic Asylums Act, most of England's counties and boroughs were able to build asylums from public monies to care for paupers who were mentally ill (Dowbiggin, 1997).

Campaigners for public asylums often described the horrors of private mad-houses as part of their arsenal of arguments for reform; however, conditions for patients with money to pay were not nearly so awful. Middle class and rich people could go to licensed houses, usually run by doctors who "opened up their own homes to patients as a species of 'paying guest'" (Murphy, 2001, p. 30). These homes tended to be cleaner, and lunatics were treated with some decency.

Meanwhile, in colonial America, madness was understood as either touched by God or bedevilment. According to McGovern (1993), mentally ill people were mostly left alone. Later, as political and social changes took place in the mid-18th century, there was less tolerance in society for lunatics and the disruption they sometimes caused. Many of the mentally ill were locked in unheated attics and sheds, kept in pest houses, or confined in jails. Haller and Larsen (2003) argue that "like eighteenth-century Europe, the United States treated insanity severely and punitively" (p. 260). Clearly, something needed to be done to make treatment more humane and to deal with the problem of growing numbers of mentally ill people in the cities. In Philadelphia, Dr. Benjamin Rush, founder of psychiatry in America, called for a new view of lunacy. The solution, it seemed, was to stop seeing the victims as wayward and to build publicly-supported asylums for the humane care and treatment of them.

The movement to build asylums was revolutionary and an abrupt departure from previous public policies toward mentally ill people (Dowbiggin, 1997). Webster's Ninth New Collegiate Dictionary defines the word asylum as "an inviolable place of refuge and protection giving shelter to criminals and debtors; a sanctuary, a place of retreat and security; an institution for the relief or care of the destitute or afflicted and especially the insane." The asylum had a double purpose -- custodial care in a safe place and "a therapeutic environment for those deemed curable" (McGovern, 1993, p. 688).

Crowded cities and high stress levels in American society had triggered a need for better care, and asylums were seen as places where expert care could be given.

No discussion of asylums would be complete without considering Dr. Thomas Kirkbride who was an influential early advocate of asylums for "moral treatment" in the United States (Kirkbride Buildings - History web site). He was strongly influenced by the ideas of Dr. Benjamin Rush in Philadelphia who preached the moral treatment of mental illness and was responsible for initiating change in the way people viewed lunatics. Instead of seeing them as moral deviants who required confinement and punishment to set them straight, enlightened people began to see them as sick people who needed to be cured.

Moral treatment was a social movement in the 19th century that began in England and France in the late 1700s with the ideas of William Tuke, a Quaker who believed that madmen should be treated with tenderness and sensitivity. At the same time, Pinel in France was instituting similar reforms. Tuke founded the York Retreat in 1796 and ran it according to the principles of the Society of Friends. No shackling was allowed, no mechanical restraints, punishments, or medicine. "The Retreat was designed as an environment that would help them [the patients] internalize discipline and restraint" (Haller & Larsen, 2005, p. 260). Some physical labor was provided as a way to foster wellness, as "The religious foundation of the York Retreat nurtured the belief that those who worked were the instruments of God's will" (cited in Haller & Larsen, 2005, p. 261). It also gave "guests" something to do.

In the 1800s, Tuke's son described mental illness as "a distortion or destruction of intellectual and moral powers" (Haller & Larsen, 2005, p. 261). Thus, the new moral treatment was designed to help the mentally ill get control back and regain intellectual and moral power. Instead of shackles and physical restraints, fear was the weapon used to combat mental illness. "There cannot be a doubt that the principle of fear, in the human mind, when moderately and judiciously excited, as it is by the operation of just and equal laws, has a salutary effect upon society" (cited in Haller & Larsen, 2005, p. 261). Thus, fear was the internal mechanism of control. Apparently, Tuke had some success re-integrating mentally ill persons back into society because Rush and Kirkbride in America were strongly influenced by his ideas.

Beginning with one in Philadelphia, Kirkbride asylums were built all over the country. Regarding the architecture of asylums, Krahn (2005) observes, "To study the processing mode of the mental asylum reveals layers of metaphor about what is human in a given culture, murmuring about who we think we are, and who we are, and how the two clash" (p. 104). One can see by examining the architecture of the Kirkbride asylums that Dr. Kirkbride believed in human beings working both the body and the mind.

The asylums were laid out in a manner to encourage or "persuade" the mental patient to return to sanity. The right surroundings were imperative. He was one of thirteen founders… READ MORE

How to Reference "Asylums in the 19th Century" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

Immigration in America: 19th Century to Present Essay

Immigration in America: 19th Century to Present

The millions of immigrants who have come to America over the past four hundred years have made America what it is today. The… read more

Essay 6 pages (2190 words) Sources: 3 Topic: American History / United States

---

Nineteenth Century Prostitution Within the Grand Catalogue Term Paper

Nineteenth Century Prostitution

Within the grand catalogue of criminal offences, the asking for a reward by a young woman in return for a sexual service must surely rate as a… read more

Term Paper 10 pages (2865 words) Sources: 8 Style: MLA Topic: Women / Feminism

---

Vincent Van Gogh Research Proposal

PAINTINGS, COLORS and Self-PORTRAIT

INTRODUCTION had a hard struggle with myself...."

Vincent van Gogh (Van Goh's Letters, 2009)

The Painter

The Painter" sold only one of his paintings, now worth… read more

Research Proposal 50 pages (14235 words) Sources: 20 Style: APA Topic: Art / Painting / Sculpture

---

Immigrant US History Essay

U.S. Immigrants

The Black and Mexican Experiences During and After World War I

The United States of America, and indeed the entire continent of North America, has been a place… read more

Essay 4 pages (1360 words) Sources: 3 Topic: World History

---

Death in Spanish Literature While the Renaissance Term Paper

Death in Spanish Literature

While the Renaissance in Europe bred abundant literature on every lively intellectual subject, the Baroque period was filled the Spanish nation with disappointment. In Europe in… read more

Term Paper 10 pages (3683 words) Sources: 3 Style: MLA Topic: Latin America / Mexico / Caribbean

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>