Research Proposal on "Aryan Nation"

/>

Like Al Qaeda, the Aryan Nations uses religion to defend its violent motives. At the root of Aryan Nations religious ideology is the Christian Identity Movement. The Christian Identity Movement is based on a nineteenth century British movement called "Anglo-Israelism," (Hoffman 2006). Proponents of Anglo-Israelism and hence, the Christian Identity Movement believe that Jesus Christ was not a Semite but an Aryan; that the twelve tribes of Israel are comprised only of "blue-eyed" Aryans; that white Anglo-Saxons are the Bible's true "chosen people," and finally, that the United States is the Biblical Promised Land (Hoffman 2006, 109).

The Christian Identity Movement differs from its predecessor in several important ways. For one, the Christian Identity Movement fused with Christian Patriotism, antifederalism, and a strong belief in conspiracy theories such as the existence of the Illuminati (Hoffman 2006). Also, the Christian Identity Movement and the Christian Patriotism movement espouse the idea of "two seeds" that spawned humanity. One seed is godly (the blue-eyed Aryans) and the other satanic (all others, especially Jews and all people of color). Christian Patriotism holds other anti-authoritarian beliefs including the notion that paper money is "fraudulent," (Hoffman 2006, 110). Finally, the Christian Identity Movement differs from Anglo-Israelism most significantly in one key way. Anglo-Israelism "embraced an entirely pacifist doctrine" whereas the Christian Identity Movement does not and even condones violence.

The Christian Identity Movement and Christian Patriotism infused their values and beliefs with those of the Church of Jesus Christ-Christian and over the course of several decades those ideals have become well articulated. Violence is justifiable against Jews, blacks, and other members of the "Satanic races" (Al-Khattar 2003, Hoffman 2006). Moreover, violence is permissible against law enforcement officials who represent the oppressive Zionist regime that is the federal government. In their summary of the Aryan Nations, the FBI defines the terrorist group as "a group of white supremacists who were heavily armed and had a dislike for law enforcement officials."

Religious fervor foments the violence of the Aryan Nation doctrine. According to Al-Khattar (2003), "most right-wing terrorism in the United States has a religious (Christian) component," (29). The Aryan Nations is indeed a prime example of religious terrorism because the group bases its philosophy on a fringe interpretation of scripture and its messianic worldview. In the same way that Al Qaeda does not represent the core beliefs of Islam, the Aryan Nations does not represent the core beliefs of Christianity. Both terrorist groups distort religion to serve a political purpose. Religion is a tool used to solidify the emotional commitment of members to the cause.

The secondary role of genuine religious faith is especially evident in the recent and startling alliance between the Aryan Nations and jihadists, Muslim religious warriors. The common ground between the Aryan Nations and the jihadists is obvious: hatred of the Jews. As Borgeson & Valeri (2009) point out, members who join the Aryan Nations hating only blacks eventually come to hate Jews too and blame Jews for "most of the world's problems," (74). Here is where the Aryan Nations distinguishes itself from other white supremacist groups like the Ku Klux Klan and the skinheads. The latter groups focus more on people of color as targets, whereas the Aryan Nations includes Jews in their repertoire.

In fact, the Aryan Nations has made hatred of the Jews a core part of its pseudo-religious agenda. Christianity -- at least the Aryan Nation version of it which hearkens to Anglo-Israelism, Christian Identity, and Christian Patriotism -- is the only true religion. The Christian Identity doctrine reinforces the belief that Jews must be specifically targeted as an enemy of the Aryan race. The Aryan Nations remains inseparable from the original Church of Jesus Christ-Christian.

Hatred of the Jews also blends easily with Aryan Nations conspiracy theories, including a Jewish-controlled banking, government, and media conglomerate. Jews are even believed to be behind the September 11 terrorist attacks (Borgeson & Valeri 2009). September 11 has given the Aryan Nations a whole new lexicon and identity. As Borgeson & Valeri (2009) note, the Aryan Nations has started to use the term "Aryan Jihad," (78). On their Web site, the Aryan Nation simply uses the term "Aryan War" to refer to its current ideology.

Using the term jihad signified the growing sympathy between the Aryan Nations and Muslim terrorist organizations like Al Qaeda. It may seem strange for a staunchly Christian and anti-Semitic group to associate itself with a staunchly Muslim and Semitic movement. Borgeson & Valeri (2009) speculate that the alliance occurred as the Aryan Nations experienced a steep drop in membership. The Muslim jihadists were heralded as a people with "spine," (Borgeson & Valeri 2009, 79).

Furthermore, religion was the only thing that the two groups did not agree on entirely. The two groups share similar views on many other issues as if religion matters very little to either group. Like the Aryan Nations, Muslim jihadists "perceived media persecution" and sought to destroy the American government (Borgeson & Valeri 2009, 79). Hoffman (2006) compares the Aryan Nations to the Palestinian Liberation Organization (PLO), as both are "umbrella groups for like-minded organizations," (110). The alliance between the Aryan Nations and Muslim jihadists also shows how religion plays only a superficial role in these two terrorist organizations. Religion is the shell, beneath which true terror teems.

Changes and Conflicts within the Aryan Nations

The Aryan Nations has experienced several organizational changes throughout its existence. The first significant change came in the mid-1980s when splinter group The Order was founded. Al-Khattar (2003) places the founding of The Order in 1983. The Order was a "radical splinter group" that "felt that more extreme tactics (violent and terrorist) were required to achieve their goals," (Hoffman 2006, 110; Al-Khattar 2003, 30). The doctrine of jihad applies particularly well to The Order, which views itself as a band of Christians dedicated to fighting a holy war. The Order uses the term "Aryan Warrior" to refer to members (Al-Khattar 2003, 30). In the initial years after it was founded, The Order posed political problems for the Aryan Nations, but now the two fall under the same rubric of white supremacist, neo-Nazi domestic terrorist groups (Hoffman 2006).

In 2000, the Aryan Nations lost a well-publicized lawsuit that spelled financial demise for the organization. Victoria and her son Jason Keenan were driving home from a wedding near the Aryan Nations compound in rural Idaho. Their car backfired, causing the Aryan Nations security guards to fire at the Keenans. Bullets struck the car, which was forced into a ditch. The Aryan Nations security guards held Victoria and Jason at gunpoint. The Southern Poverty Law Center advocated for the Keenans, and the trial only lasted one week. The jury awarded $6.3 million dollars plus the 20-acre compound to the Keenans in the verdict, ruling Pastor Butler guilty of gross negligence. The Keenans later sold the compound at Hayden Lake to a philanthropic organization.

Losing the compound had a significant impact on the Aryan Nations, which refers to the lawsuit as "erroneous." The Aryan Nations admit being more decentralized in their organizational structure. In 2004, founder Pastor Richard G. Butler died. The leadership vacuum meant even more decentralization of the Aryan Nations. The organization claims that decentralization has increased the proliferation of splinter cells that are "taking action into their own hands after the diaspora from the Hayden Lake compound," (Aryan Nations). Since then, the Aryan Nations reestablished its headquarters in Potter County, Pennsylvania. Before his death Butler… READ MORE