Term Paper on "Andrea Yates Insanity Defense"

Term Paper 5 pages (1476 words) Sources: 3 Style: APA

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Andrea Yates Insanity Defense

Insanity Defense: The Andrea Yates Case

Case Summary

Born on July 2, 1964, she had a normal childhood and was the picture of success. Andrea Yates (Kennedy) launched successful career as a registered nurse at the University of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center from 1986 until 1994 (Montaldo, 2007). On April 17, 1993, she married Rusty Yates. In eight years of marriage, she produced five children; four boys and one girl (Montaldo, 2007). It was after the birth of her second child that friends say the changes began to occur. She stopped jogging and became isolated. They decided to home school the children, compounding the isolation (Montaldo, 2007).

In 1996, Rusty accepted work in Florida and the family moved into a 38-foot travel trailer. In 1997, Rusty purchased a 350-square foot renovated bus to house the growing family (Montaldo, 2007). Conditions were cramped and this was when Andrea's insanity began to surface. On June 16, 1999, her husband was called home from work to find her shaking involuntarily and chewing on her fingers. The next day she attempted to commit suicide by taking an overdose of sleeping pills (Montaldo, 2007).

She was transferred to Methodist Hospital Psychiatric Unit and diagnosed with major depressive disorder. She was prescribed antidepressants, but refused to take them. Soon after, she began mutilating herself and refusing to feed her children, claiming that they were too fat (Montaldo, 2007). She thought that there were video cameras on the ceilings and said that the characters on TV were talking to her children (Montaldo, 2007). On July 20, 1999, she put a knife to her own neck and begged her husband to let her die. She was once again hospitalized and was catatonic for 10 days. After receiving the anti-psychotic drug Haldol, she immediately improved. Rusty bought a nice house in a nice neighborhood. Andrea began to return to her own self, swimming, socializing, and interacting with her children (Montaldo, 2007). Things looked good.

In March of 2000, Andrea became pregnant and stopped taking Haldol. On November 30, 2000, daughter Mary was born (Montaldo, 2007). Andrea was coping, but on March 12, 2001, her father died, sending her into a digression. She stopped taking liquids and mutilated herself. She would not feed Mary and began frantically Bible (Montaldo, 2007). She went to a different hospital where she was briefly put on Haldol. It was discontinued, because her psychiatrist did not feel that she seemed psychotic (Montaldo, 2007).

Andrea was released, but returned in May. She was released in 10 days and told to "think positive thoughts" and to see a psychologist. Two days after the follow up visit from her latest psychiatric stay, Andrea waited for her husband to leave for work and systematically drowned her five children (Montaldo, 2007). She then took them to her bed and covered them up (Montaldo, 2007). She then called 911 and requested that a police officer come to her house. She did not ask for an ambulance, but for a police officer (Montaldo, 2007). After the police were on the way, she called her husband and told him, "You need to come home... it's time. I did it." When he asked what she meant, she replied "It's the children... all of them" (Ramsland, 2007).

Summary of Arguments

The defense of insanity was obvious from the beginning. In this case, Andrea had a long history of psychotic behavior, attempted suicide, and numerous hospitalizations. She had a record of hallucinations and had been on an anti-psychotic drug for an extended period of time. There were a number of expert witnesses, including former doctors, that would support the insanity defense. The defense attorney had a stack of medical documents which supported the argument that Andrea had a serious illness that caused her to act irrationally, even to the point of putting a knife to her own throat. This appeared to be an "easy" insanity defense from a legal standpoint.

However, Texas law leaves a large gap between insanity and murder. In order for an insanity defense to stand, the defense must prove that at the time of the acts, the person did not "know" right from "wrong," or that they were not aware of what they were doing at the time. These terms are not concrete and unlike other states, Texas does not inform the jury of the proper definitions of the terms involved in the case (Dix,… READ MORE

How to Reference "Andrea Yates Insanity Defense" Term Paper in a Bibliography

Related Term Papers:

Judicial Process: The Insanity Defense Since 1724 Essay

Judicial Process: The Insanity Defense

Since 1724, there have been records of the insanity defense being used in trials. Before that time, there was no difference in the eyes of… read more

Essay 8 pages (2832 words) Sources: 8 Topic: Crime / Police / Criminal Justice

---

Schizophrenia and Society Essay

Schizophrenia and Society

Houston born, Andrea Yates was born to a German immigrant, Jutta Karin Koehler. She had five siblings and she was the youngest of all being raised in… read more

Essay 3 pages (1131 words) Sources: 5 Topic: Psychology / Behavior / Psychiatry

---

Debating and Defending Issues Essay

Similarly, men have also been enabled to take on an expanded role in terms of nurturing and general parenting that they could not in the past. Therefore, the changes to… read more

Essay 12 pages (4149 words) Sources: 12 Topic:

---

Women Who Kill Their Children Research Paper

Women Who Kill Their Children

The Nature of the Unnatural:

On January 27th of this year, Julie Powers, a 50-year-old mother from Tampa, Florida, shot her two teenage children to… read more

Research Paper 8 pages (2425 words) Sources: 8 Topic: Child Development / Youth / Teens

---

Death Penalty Few Issues Thesis

Death Penalty

Few issues in the United States, and indeed worldwide, criminal justice system have been as widely debated and contested as the death penalty. Proponents hold that the death… read more

Thesis 5 pages (1687 words) Sources: 5 Style: APA Topic: Crime / Police / Criminal Justice

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>