Article Critique on "Administrative Evil"

Article Critique 3 pages (1311 words) Sources: 3

[EXCERPT] . . . .

Administrative Evil as a Social Construct

The reality that Dubnick & Justice (2006) attempt to address in the present article is simply that evil is a seemingly inherent byproduct of human affairs and interactions. Evil events occur and beyond this, are often facilitated by a rhetorical inversion of conventional ethical principles even to the extent that acts now viewed in hindsight as evil such as the institution of slavery or the various genocides which have been recorded in human events were at one time justified on distorted ethical rationales. In an effort to find a rational way of examining the seeming inevitability of such evil, researchers beginning with Adams & Balfour in 1998, have characterized this as 'administrative evil.' The discussion hereafter will evaluate this concept, attempting to define the perspective underlying this phrase and to evaluate the ethical and philosophical implications of such a perspective.

Key Tenets:

The primary tenet that drives the discussion in the article by Dubnick & Justice is that evil behaviors cannot simply be prevented simply through the use of ethical rhetoric. The inevitability of 'administrative evil' instead calls for an objective way of evaluating and understanding this evil. Accordingly, a key tenet of the article is that 'administrative evil' is best understood as a function of the culture and society within which it is allowed to occur. To this point, the article proposes to "explore the role of evil in administrative ethics from a functional perspetive, accepting its importance as a socially significant concept that requires attention on those grounds alone. Posited within the historical context of modernity, we find that various notions of evil have served (and continue to serve) a social purpose in both rationalizing and transforming otherwise morally inexplicable events and behavior. Understood in this way, evil has indeed played a key role in modern life, although more as a mediating social construct than as an actual metaphysical or natural force." (Dubnick & Justice, p. 237)

This contributes the tenet that when we make efforts to understand evil as a social construct, it is easier to view the consequences of this dysfunction.

Pros/Cons:

The article explicitly states that its consideration is not without its limits. To the point, the authors concede that the article is largely analytical and philosophical in nature. The article is therefore not to be perceived as a scientific research document nor do the authors wish to have their analysis perceived as a theory. Lacking any such empiricism, the article's primary drawback is the relatively unsupportable nature of its conclusions.

That said, the article is valuable to the extent that it explicitly proclaims to be, as a catalyst to a more open and honest discussion on the issues breached. Certainly, there is a tremendous value to placing a more objective and rational discussion around the concept of evil. As the text by Dubnick & Justice notes, the concept of evil has always troubled philosophers of morality and social convention. They remark that "in ethics, the challenge of evil is to deal with those actions that, by definition, defy moral comprehension. Despite its use in political rhetoric aand everyday life, the term evil remains ambiguous at best, a holographic concept that we see without being able to grasp its meaning." (Dubnick & Justice, p. 239) It is this very nature that renders the discussion on 'administrative evil' so categorically important. In administrative contexts such as governments or corporations, the proposition of ethical orientation may apply, but only in a supplemental context to institutionalized notions of ethical behavior that are likely to incorporate some degree of 'administrative evil.' This article is strongly recommended by its capacity to bring more balanced attention to this sometimes precarious balance between ethical orientation and the pressure of social constructs.

Application to Public Administration:

The article by Browder (2001) sums up well the application to public administration of a discussion such as Dubnick & Justice's. Particularly, Browder suggests that by… READ MORE

How to Reference "Administrative Evil" Article Critique in a Bibliography

Related Article Critiques:

Privacy Rights Term Paper

Privacy Rights

In the case of Wilson vs. Layne that was argued in March 24, 1999, and was decided in May 24, 1999, the privacy rights of the citizen, Charles… read more

Term Paper 15 pages (6316 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Crime / Police / Criminal Justice

---

German Imperial Colonialism Research Paper

The state passed travel bans in the late 1890s and early 1900s to limit the how of people and information between colony and metropole precisely because such border crossing was… read more

Research Paper 30 pages (8862 words) Sources: 19 Topic: World History

---

Chinese History How Genghis Khan Essay

Chinese History

How Genghis Khan and His Mongols Takeover of China Had an Overall Good Effect on China.

The Mongols played a much more important role in history than did… read more

Essay 6 pages (1766 words) Sources: 3 Topic: Asian History / Asia

---

Hmong This Saying, Attributed to William Osler Essay

Hmong

This saying, attributed to William Osler, is the preface of the book by clinical neurologist Oliver Sacks called An Anthropologist on Mars. He is also the author of the… read more

Essay 5 pages (1548 words) Sources: 0 Style: MLA Topic: Healthcare / Health / Obamacare

---

Public Diplomacy Term Paper

Congress of Vienna, amidst the height of the turbulent end to the Napoleonic era, Metternich was informed of the death of the Russian ambassador and exclaimed, "Ah, is that true?… read more

Term Paper 15 pages (4687 words) Sources: 1+ Topic: Government / Politics

---

View 100+ more related papers  >>